Tag: Tâlât Paşa

  • Armenian news outlet cannot resist fakery

    Armenian news outlet cannot resist fakery

    Ferruh Demirmen, Ph.D. 

    Public Radio of Armenia, one of the largest broadcasters in Armenia, and which also acts as a news outlet on the Internet, evidently cannot resist fakery as it advocates “Armenian genocide.” In its March 15, 2021 edition, the news outlet featured the assassination of Mehmet Talaat Pasha, the Ottoman Minister of Interior Affairs, on March 15, 1921 in Berlin by a young Armenian named Soghomon Tehlirian. The news outlet used the anniversary of the assassination as an opportunity for a propaganda hit to publicize “Armenian genocide.” 

    But as revealed by this author, the news coverage exposed a shameful fakery.

    Fig. 1 shows how the headline appeared when the article was first published on March 15, 2021.

    newyork times 15 mart 1921 talat pasa

    The headline was a fraudulent reproduction of the headline of the news coverage by the Berlin (March 15) and New York (March 16) offices of The New York Times. There was no resemblance between the fake headline and the actual Times headlines.

    Most notable, was that the fake headline contained the word “genocide” – a term that did not exist until the Polish lawyer Raphael Lemkin coined it in 1944. The Times headlines of the Berlin and New York offices did not contain the word “genocide.”

    The fakery prompted this author to write to the Times on March 23, 2021 to inform the newspaper of the fakery by providing the images of the actual and faked headlines. It was left to the judgment of the newspaper as to whether to take action vis-a-vis the fakery, including a stern warning or legal action, if need be. At the very least, Public Radio of Armenia had deceived its readers and breached journalistic ethics The newspaper did not respond.

    This is where the situation stood until this author happened to re-visit the same news coverage around June 1 (2022): . Most surprisingly, although the news Internet link had not changed, the headline had changed as shown in Fig. 2.

    Talaat Pasha talat pasanin katili

    The fake headline had disappeared, and there was no explanation as to the reason. One explanation for the change was that the Times had contacted the publisher and demanded correction, possibly under threat of a lawsuit.

    The other explanation is that the publisher took note of this author’s Diplomatic Observer article and took its own initiative.

    However, there was more surprise. When the same news coverage was visited around end-June (2022) through the same Internet link, both the fake (Fig.1) and the corrected headline (Fig. 2) appeared. The publisher somehow could not resist re-invigorating the fake headline.

    The over-all impression was that, the publisher was simply making mockery of the truth, and playing games with the readers. One wonders whether the Times is aware of such disrespectful behavior.

    But the bigger question is: Why did Public Radio of Armenia resort to the shameful deception in the first place? Deception by Armenian sources as to the alleged “Armenian genocide” is not new, e.g., the “Andonian telegrams,” the “Hitler quote,” the “pyramids of human skulls,” the ECtHR Switzerland-Perinçek “victory verdict,” and the alleged Subatan (Kars) massacre, which in fact is the savagery inflicted by Armenian militants on Muslim civilians. Evidently the best way to propagandize a falsified “Armenian genocide” is through fake news!

  • The Talaat Pasha Question

    The Talaat Pasha Question

    Dr Pat Walsh is a political analyst and historian. He has written a number of books on the Great War of 1914 and the Armenian question. His latest book, ‘Britain against Russia in the Caucasus: Ottoman Turks, Armenians and Azerbaijanis caught up in Geopolitics, War and Revolution’ will be published shortly by Manzara Verlag. In the following piece Dr Walsh reviews Prof. Hans Keiser’s recent book on Talaat Pasha.

    drpatwalsh.com/2020/06/13/the-talaat-pasha-question/

    Talat Paşa
    Talat Paşa
  • Soghomon Tehlirian to be Commemorated in Berlin

    Soghomon Tehlirian to be Commemorated in Berlin

    Soghomon Tehlirian

    BERLIN (ArmRadio)–It was on March 15, 1921 that Armenian avenger Soghomon Tehlirian assassinated Talaat Pasha, one of the masterminds of the Armenian Genocide.

    On April 2, 120th anniversary of Tehlirian’s birth, representatives of the Armenian community will gather on Hardenbergstraße in Berlin, the site where Talaat was assassinated, to hold an event in memory of Tehlirian

    Tehlirian shadowed Talaat as he left his house on Hardenbergstraße on the morning of March 15, 1921. He crossed the street to view him from the opposite sidewalk, then crossed it once more to walk past him to confirm his identity. He then turned around and pointed his gun to shoot him in the nape of the neck.

    Talaat was felled with a single 9mm parabellum round from a Luger P08 pistol. The assassination took place in broad daylight and led to Tehlirian’s immediate arrest by German police.

    “I killed him, but I am not a murderer,” Tehlirian said of himself.

    After a two-day trial, Tehlirian was found not guilty by the German court, and freed. He eventually moved to the United States and lived out his years in San Francisco.

    Discussion Policy

    Comments are welcomed and encouraged. Though you are fully responsible for the content you post, comments that include profanity, personal attacks or other inappropriate material will not be permitted. Asbarez reserves the right to block users who violate any of our posting standards and policies.

  • Talaat’s Personal Account of The Armenian Massacres

    Talaat’s Personal Account of The Armenian Massacres

    SASSUN-4
    ,

    In my last week’s column, I reported that Talaat Pasha, the mastermind of the Armenian Genocide, had told British intelligence officer Aubrey Herbert in 1921 that he had written “a memorandum on the Armenian massacres.”

    I would like now to present brief excerpts from Talaat’s lengthy account published in the November 1921 issue of Current History, the monthly magazine of The New York Times, titled: “Posthumous Memoirs of Talaat Pasha,” and subtitled: “The former Grand Vizier’s own account, written shortly before his assassination, of why and how Turkey entered the war — Secret alliance that preceded the conflict — Causes of the Armenian massacres as stated by the man who ordered them.”

    In an introductory note, Current History editors explain how they obtained a copy of this revealing report: “…After Talaat’s death, the manuscript passed into the possession of his wife, who remained in Germany; she has not yet published the whole of it, but after the acquittal of her husband’s assassin she permitted the Paris correspondent of Vakit, a liberal Turkish newspaper published in Constantinople, to reproduce the most interesting portions of it. These have been translated from Turkish for Current History by M. Zekeria, a native of Constantinople. They represent about fifty pages of the original manuscript, the opening sentence of which, ‘I do not tell all the truth, but all I tell is truth,’ aroused a great sensation in Turkey.”

    In his memoirs, as in his interview with Aubrey Herbert, Talaat tries to exonerate himself by blaming everyone else — Armenians, Russians, even Turks — for the Armenian massacres. He does not deny “the deportations of the Armenians, in some localities of the Greeks, and in Syria of some of the Arabs,” but claims that such reports “were exceedingly exaggerated.” Talaat then adds: “in saying this, I do not mean to deny the facts. I desire only to eliminate the exaggerations and to relate the facts as they occurred.”

    The former Grand Vizier confesses: “I admit that we deported many Armenians from our eastern provinces, but we never acted in this matter upon a previously prepared scheme. The responsibility for these acts falls first of all upon the deported people themselves. Russia, in order to lay hand on our eastern provinces, had armed and equipped the Armenian inhabitants of this district, and had organized strong Armenian bandit forces in the said area.”

    Attempting to repair his tarnished image, Talaat acknowledges the Turkish brutalities against Armenians: “I admit also that the deportation was not carried out lawfully everywhere. In some places unlawful acts were committed…. Some of the officials abused their authority, and in many places people took preventive measures into their own hands and innocent people were molested. I confess it.”

    Continuing his face-saving rhetoric, Talaat concedes: “I confess, also, that the duty of the Government was to prevent these abuses and atrocities or at least to hunt down and punish their perpetrators severely. In many places, where the property and goods of the deported people were looted, and the Armenians molested, we did arrest those who were responsible and punished them according to the law. I confess, however, that we ought to have acted more sternly, opened up a general investigation for the purpose of finding out all the promoters and looters and punished them severely. But we could not do that. Although we punished many of the guilty, most of them were untouched.”

    Talaat proceeds to provide excuses for not pursuing perpetrators of the Armenian massacres who “were short-sighted, fanatic, and yet sincere in their belief. The public encouraged them, and they had general approval behind them. They were numerous and strong. Their open and immediate punishment would have aroused great discontent among the people, who favored their acts. An endeavor to arrest and to punish all these promoters would have created anarchy in Anatolia at a time when we greatly needed unity.”

    To set the record straight, Talaat’s claims that Armenians stabbed Turkey in the back during WWI are completely false. Minister of War Enver Pasha, Commander-in-Chief of the Ottoman Armed Forces, in a letter to the Bishop of Konya, praised the bravery of Turkish-Armenian soldiers fighting against the Russian Army in the winter of 1914-1915.

    Ironically, Talaat’s assertion that his government would have taken brutal actions against Armenians even at “a time of peace,” reconfirms long-standing Turkish genocidal practices as previously demonstrated by the Hamidian and Adana massacres of Armenians which were carried out when there were no wars.

  • Genocidaire Talaat’s Last Interview Shortly Before his Assassination

    Genocidaire Talaat’s Last Interview Shortly Before his Assassination

    SASSUN-4

    Aubrey Herbert, British diplomat, adventurer, intelligence officer, and Member of Parliament, conducted a rare interview with Talaat Pasha, in February 1921, just days before his assassination in Berlin by Soghomon Tehlirian.

    As all-powerful Grand Vizier of the Ottoman Empire, its despotic ruler and mastermind of the Armenian Genocide, Talaat had fled Turkey in November 1918 to avoid prosecution by the new regime. The 23-page interview with Talaat was published in 1924 (London) and 1925 (New York) in Herbert’s memoirs titled, “Ben Kendim: A Record of Eastern Travel.”

    Herbert first met Talaat in 1908 while stationed at the British Embassy in Constantinople (Istanbul). Eleven years later, Herbert received an unexpected letter from Talaat seeking a meeting with him “in any neutral country.” Desperately seeking to rehabilitate his diabolical image in the West, Talaat claimed that “he was not responsible for the Armenian massacres, that he could prove it, and that he was anxious to do so.” Herbert turned down Talaat’s request telling him: “I was very glad to hear that it was not he who was responsible for the Armenian massacres, but that I did not think any useful purpose could be served by our meeting at that time.”

    However, Herbert reversed his decision in February 1921, after Sir Basil Thomson, Director of British Intelligence, ordered him to leave immediately for Germany and meet Talaat. The secret rendezvous took place on February 26, in the small German town of Hamm.

    Talaat told Herbert again that “he himself had always been against the attempted extermination of the Armenians.” More incredibly, Talaat claimed that “he had twice protested against this policy, but had been overruled, he said, by the Germans.”

    Forgetting his own claims of innocence in the massacres, Talaat justified the mass killings by accusing Armenians of stabbing his country in the back during the war. Contradicting himself again, Talaat declared his support for Armenians by claiming that “he was in favor of granting autonomy to minorities in the most extended form, and would gladly consider any proposition that was made to him.”

    Talaat then switched the blame to the British for the Armenian killings: “You English cannot divest yourselves of responsibility in this matter. We Young Turks practically offered Turkey to you, and you refused us. One undoubted consequence has been the ruin of Christian minorities, whom your Prime Minister has insisted on treating as your allies. If the Greeks and Armenians are your allies when we are at war with you, you cannot expect our Turkish Government to treat them as friends.”

    Herbert and Talaat then decided to move to Dusseldorf, Germany, where they continued their discreet conversation for two more days. Herbert reported Talaat’s paradoxical attempt to cover up his role in the Armenian Genocide, while justifying this heinous crime. Talaat stated that “he had written a memorandum on the Armenian massacres which he was very anxious that British statesmen should read. Early in the war, in 1915, the Armenians had organized an army, and had attacked the Turks, who were then fighting the Russians. Three Armenian deputies had taken an active part; the alleged massacres of Moslems had taken place, accompanied by atrocities on women and children. He had twice opposed enforced migration, and he had been the author of an inquiry which resulted in the execution of a number of guilty Kurds and Turks.”

    Ironically, Talaat boldly told Herbert that he was not afraid of being assassinated. “He said that he never thought of it. Why should anyone dislike him? I said that Armenians might very well desire vengeance, after all that had been written about him in the papers. He brushed this aside.” Two weeks later, Talaat was assassinated in Berlin by Soghomon Tehlirian!

    Concluding his interview of Talaat, Herbert observed: “He died hated, indeed execrated, as few men have been in their generation. He may have been all that he was painted — I cannot say. I know that he had rare power and attraction. I do not know whether he was responsible or not for the Armenian massacres.”

    Only experts of that time period can verify the authenticity and accuracy of this lengthy interview. If true, what exactly were Talaat’s aims in proposing “an Anglo-Turkish alliance” and why was the British government so anxious to talk to him?

  • “ÖNCE VATAN” Andonian Paçavraları

    “ÖNCE VATAN” Andonian Paçavraları

    Aram Andonian  (1875, İstanbul – 1952, Paris)
    Aram Andonian (1875, İstanbul – 1952, Paris)

     

    Yazar ve sahtekâr sıfatlarına sahip Aram Andonian, 1920 yılında Naim Bey’in Hatıraları, adında bir kitap yazmış, bunu üç dilde İngilizce, Fransızca ve Ermenice yayınlamıştır. Kitapta sözü edilen sözde “belgeleri” Osmanlı liderlerine, özellikle Tâlât Paşa’ya mâl etmiş, ama hiçbir zaman asıllarını gösteremediği bu belgeleri daha sonra da kaybettiğini belirtmiştir.

    1. Dünya Savaşı’nın galip devletleri, daha sonra kimisi Malta’da alıkonacak olan Osmanlı liderleri suçlayabilecekleri belgeleri köşe bucak ararken, Andonian’ın ürettiği bu “telgrafllar”a hiç itibar etmemişlerdir. Aram Andonian sonunda, (26 Temmuz 1937 tarihli) Cenevre’ de (İsviçre) oturan bir Ermeni hanımefendiye (Mary Terziyan) yazdığı mektupta, kitabının bir tarih kitabı değil, bir propaganda çalışması olduğunu ve diğer kimselerin bu kitabı nasıl istiyorlarsa öyle kullandıklarını itiraf etmiştir.

    2007 senesinde kaybettiğimiz ve değerini ve dostluğunu yeterince bilemediğimiz Avusturyalı araştırmacı yazar Eric Feigl’in “Ermeni Mitomanyası” adlı kitabındaki önsözünden:

    Elbette, araştırmalarım sırasında başka birçok kişiyle tanıştım. Özellikle Ermeni Zoryan Enstitüsü Başkanı Dr. Gerard Libaridian’ı da anmak isterim. Dr. Libaridian ile Cambridge, Massachusetts’deki ofisinde uzun saatler geçirdik ve çok ilginç konuşmalar yaptık. Dr. Libaridian, zeki, hayat dolu, bilgili, becerikli ve kendine güvenen biri. Onunla yaptığımız konuşmaları konu alan bir oyun bile yazılabilir.


    Bu konuşma sırasında, ev sahibimin en ateşli ifadelerini sürekli not aldım. Birçok defa sözde “Andonian Belgeleri”nden bahsetti.

    Dr. Libaridian’ın bu belgelerin uydurma olduklarını bildiğini düşünmek makul gözüktüğünden, konuyla ilgili tek bir kelime üzerinde zaman harcamak istemedim. Konuşulacak daha ilginç birçok konu vardı. Ama özellikle, Aram Andonian’ın kitabı ve bu kitabın belgeleri üzerinde durdu.

    Sonunda, “Ama Dr. Libaridian, benim gibi siz de biliyorsunuz ki, ‘Andonian Belgeleri’ uydurmadır,”demek zorunda kaldım.

    Dr. Libaridian’ın, sitemkâr cümleme verdiği kısa ve net cevabını ve yüzündeki ifadeyi hiç unutmayacağım:
    “Eeee?”

    ***

    Eric Feigl  (1931 – 27 Ocak 2007)
    Eric Feigl (1931 – 27 Ocak 2007)

     

    Aram Andonian’ın sahte belgeleri ve bu belgelerin Ermeni yalanlarındaki rolü hakkındaki yazının tamamını ekte bulabilirsiniz.

    Yazının tamamı, Eric Feigl’in “Ermeni Mitomanyası” adlı kitabından alınmıştır.

     

    Download