Tag: Armenian History

  • Erasing traces of Armenian presence: Turkey accused of misrepresenting history of monuments

    Erasing traces of Armenian presence: Turkey accused of misrepresenting history of monuments

    By Gayane Abrahamyan

    Armenian experts are warning that in Turkey almost everywhere panels telling about Armenian monuments present distorted information, which shows a consistent attempt by Turks to erase Armenian traces inside what now is within the borders of their state.

    Rafik Kurtushyan Samvel Karapetyan“While generally signs and notices placed near monuments are designed to inform tourists, in Turkey their special purpose is to mislead them and present a totally different history,” says specialist in Oriental studies Raffi Kortoshyan, who works as an expert for Research on Armenian Architecture NGO.

    One of such outrageous examples cited by Armenian experts is the huge information panel near the ruins of Ani that presents the history of the area beginning from the Stone Age and chronologically presents almost everything, except its Armenian period, while the royal Armenian dynasty of the Bagratunis is presented as the Bagratoglu emirate.

    “Perhaps they did not have enough space for Armenians,” Kortoshyan comments with irony, adding that such cases aren’t inadvertent omissions but rather amount to a consistent policy in Turkey.

    “Often we see that when a brazen lie is written on a panel, it only has one variant, in Turkish, while in English this passage is omitted, because they realize that the lie is too blatant,” he says.

    Experts at the monuments studying NGO highlight the important of the joint initiative of the Turkish government and the World Monuments Fund to restore the St. Savior Church and the Cathedral of Ani, but they believe the results of the restoration work will be questionable unless Armenian specialists are engaged in the projects.

    NGO head Samvel Karapetyan says that under the guise of restoration work they also distort the original Armenian architectural form.

    “They try to restore it, but in reality we see wrong restoration and distortions. A visual image distortion is committed and it seems to me that there is no desire and their professional ability is not enough to implement proper restoration,” says Karapetyan.

    He says according to his information there is no desire yet to engage Armenian specialists in the restoration project in Ani.

    via Erasing traces of Armenian presence: Turkey accused of misrepresenting history of monuments – News | ArmeniaNow.com.

  • An Armenian Manifesto Circa 1923: Dashnagtzoutiun Has Nothing to Do Anymore

    An Armenian Manifesto Circa 1923: Dashnagtzoutiun Has Nothing to Do Anymore

    Arnold Reisman
    Reisman and Associates

    November 20, 2010

    Abstract:
    hovhannesIn 1923 Hovhannēs Katchaznouni the first Prime Minister of the Armenian state delivered a report to an Armenian Congress in Bucharest. Referred to as his Manifesto, it was written in Armenian and self-published in the same year. The Manifesto represents a historical document of great significance to a highly charged and contested debate. For many decades its existence was unknown to most scholars. Except for one abridged version, the other versions are inaccessible because they have been willfully removed from the world’s libraries by political partisans and the latest commercially produced edition has yet to make an appearance on library shelves.

    Two currently available editions are reviewed in this paper on a per-paragraph basis and shown to be consistent on many matters pertaining to Armenian-Turkish issues. Yet they do differ substantially on other significant points. Irrespective of the edition; scholars, opinion makers, policy makers, and concerned people at large should find the information contained of great value since it comes from a most knowledgeable and credible source.

    Keywords: Armenia, Turkey, Armenian Manifesto, Katchaznouni, Dashnagtzoutiun, Dashnag, Armenian History

    JEL Classifications: B30,B31,P30, N40

    Working Paper Series

    Download full document at : https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1712564