Category: Syria

  • Kurds Look Beyond Assad, With Dreams of Autonomy

    Kurds Look Beyond Assad, With Dreams of Autonomy

    By FARNAZ FASSIHI in Beirut and a Wall Street Journal Reporter

    Leaders of Syria’s large minority Kurdish population show signs of organizing against the regime of President Bashar al-Assad, a movement with the potential to tip the domestic balance against Mr. Assad and complicate regional politics.

    Syria’s six-month prodemocracy movement has had only limited participation so far from the country’s estimated 1.7 million Kurds. Several young Kurds have been active in protests and are members of the alliance of young activists that organizes demonstrations, but the cities in predominantly Kurdish areas have been largely quiet.

    WO AH196 KURDS G 20110928184013

    Agence France-Presse/Getty ImagesSyrian Kurds from the EU, U.S. and Arabian Gulf meeting at a conference in Stockholm in early September.

    More

    • Syria Opposition Seeks No-Fly Zone

    This doesn’t translate into support for Mr. Assad, however, given the long-tense relationship between the ruling regime and the minority Kurds, against which it long discriminated.

    Kurdish activists and analysts say that in the past three weeks, members of the 11 unofficial Kurdish political parties have met with Kurdish activists from the Local Coordination Committee, an alliance for young protest organizers, to plan for a post-Assad period. These Kurdish parties plan to name a special committee and hold a conference in Syria within the next few weeks, activists say.

    Such a Kurdish group would be unrelated to the recently formed Syrian National Council, the country’s largest opposition umbrella. While Kurds say they share the opposition’s overall goal of a democratic Syria, many Kurds have also expressed frustration at what they see as protesters’ Arab agenda, and also say they aspire to greater autonomy within Syria.

    “Syrian Kurds are not looking to separate from Syria—though of course the idea of a Kurdistan is a dream,” said Meshal Tammo, the spokesman for the Kurdish Future Movement, a political grouping in northeastern Syria.

    Many of the estimated 16 million Kurds spread across Iran, Iraq, Turkey and Syria look to the autonomous Kurdish Northern Iraq as a model of governance. Many in Syria say they would support creating a similar federalized or autonomous zone.

    “If the [Assad] regime is gone, it will offer an opportunity for the Kurds to push forward for autonomy, and of course they will try,” said Joost Hiltermann, an expert on Kurds and deputy program director of Middle East for the International Crisis Group.

    Such a move would agitate Turkey and Iran, which have tried for years to crush separatist aspirations of their own Kurdish populations. As Syrian unrest has spread in the past few months, Iran and Turkey have stepped up attacks against Kurdish separatist groups PKK and PJAK along their borders with Northern Iraq.

    The Assad regime—under the current president and under his father, Hafez al-Assad—has long discriminated against the Kurds. More than 500,000 Kurds had no citizenship and few prospects for obtaining it, and couldn’t travel, own property or enroll in school. Kurds aren’t allowed to speak Kurdish or teach it in school.

    When Syrian protests broke out in mid-March, Kurdish activists said they held back from protesting, to prevent the government from framing the protests as ethnic uprising.

    The regime has circled cautiously around the Kurds, largely refraining from using lethal force against protestors in Kurdish areas. Only a handful of Kurds have been among the 2,700 people the U.N. says have been killed during amid the protests. As one of his earliest concessions when demonstrations broke out in mid-March, Mr. Assad in April pledged to grant citizenship to Kurds, though Kurdish activists say only 45,000 have legalized their status.

    Many Kurds worry that if Mr. Assad falls from power, their rights will not be secured if nationalist Sunnis Arabs gain control or if Islamists have more say in Syrian politics.

    “The Kurds are no different from anyone else in Syria—they are scared of what will come afterwards,” said Mr. Tammo of the Kurdish Future Movement.

    In Syria, Arab and Kurdish divides are increasingly exacerbated as Kurds have boycotted a number of opposition conferences held outside of Syria, saying their demands have been overlooked. Kurds walked out of the first conference in July held in Turkey over disagreement over keeping the word “Arab” in the title of the country.

    “It was a question of respect: Obviously there are greater issues than Kurdish grievances at stake, but Kurds need to be assured that they are an important part of a future Syria,” said Massoud Akko, a Kurdish author and activist exiled in Norway, who was among those who left.

    In early September, about 50 Syrian Kurds held a solidarity conference in Stockholm and issued a statement that said, “The Syrian revolution will not be complete without a just solution to the Kurdish cause.”

    Write to Farnaz Fassihi at farnaz.fassihi@wsj.com

  • Turkey denies asking Syria to give Brotherhood government posts

    Turkey denies asking Syria to give Brotherhood government posts

    ISTANBUL: Turkey Friday denied as “black propaganda” claims it asked Syria to offer the banned Muslim Brotherhood government posts in exchange for Turkey’s support in ending rallies in Syria.

    “Those allegations have nothing to do with the truth,” Selcuk Unal, the Foreign Ministry spokesman said.

    The statement he made said “favoring any political, ideological, ethnic or sectarian group or making any one of them subjects to bargaining [in Syria] was out of question” for Turkey.

    He said Turkey had repeatedly told Syria to start reforms “to ensure a transition to parliamentary democracy.”

    “Under this context we suggested them to allow all democratic entities on the political spectrum to be active in Syria and participate in the political transition process,” Unal said.

    According to Syrian officials and Western diplomats, Ankara asked Damascus to offer the Muslim Brotherhood government posts in exchange for Turkey’s support in ending rallies against Syrian President Bashar Assad but the offer was rejected.

    The Muslim Brotherhood has been banned in Syria since the rise of the Baath Party to power in 1963.

    They unsuccessfully tried to organize the population against Assad’s father and predecessor, Hafez, who brutally repressed a 1982 revolt in the city of Hama, leaving around 20,000 people dead.

    Law 49, issued in July 1980 and still in force, makes it a “criminal offense punishable by death to be affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood.”

    Thousands of the organization’s members have languished in Syria’s prisons for decades, though some have been released.

    On Aug. 9, Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu delivered a written message to Assad from President Abdullah Gul, who belonged to organizations close to the Muslim Brotherhood before forming Turkey’s ruling Justice and Development Party

    “We hope that some measures will be taken in the coming days to end the bloodshed and open the way to a process for political reform,” Davutoglu said at Ankara airport upon his return from the one-day trip to Syria last month.

    “In June, Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan offered, if Syrian President Bashar Assad ensured between a quarter and a third of ministers in his government were members of the Muslim Brotherhood, to make a commitment to use all his influence to end the rebellion,” a Western diplomat told AFP.

    Turkey has expressed its frustration with Assad and his iron-fisted regime for its failure to listen to the people, whose almost daily demonstrations for democracy have been repeatedly met with violent repression, at a cost of more than 2,700 lives according to the United Nations.

     

    A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Daily Star on October 01, 2011, on page 9.

    via THE DAILY STAR :: News :: Middle East :: Turkey denies asking Syria to give Brotherhood government posts.

  • Turkey to press ahead with sanctions against Syria

    Turkey to press ahead with sanctions against Syria

    Turkey to press ahead with sanctions against Syria

    Erdogan 007

    Despite Europe’s failure at UN, Ankara expected to go it alone in imposing sanctions on Assad regime over crackdown on protesters

    Turkey’s prime minister Recep Erdogan is expected to announce sanctions against the Syrian regime. Photograph: AP

    Turkey is pressing ahead with plans to impose its own sanctions on Syria, despite European powers backing down from using the UN to punish the regime for its crackdown on the protest movement.

    The Turkish measures are likely to be announced early next month, following a visit prime minister Recap Erdogan to camps in southern Turkey holding refugees who fled violence across the border and fear reprisals by security forces if they return.

    Four European heavyweights – France, Britain, Germany and Portugal – were forced to abandon a recent attempt to use the UN security council to impose sanctions on Syria, following opposition from Russia, China and South Africa.

    The four are now working on a watered-down resolution to threaten sanctions if the regime, led by President Bashar al-Assad, does not change its approach.

    In the absence of UN security council action, Turkey’s move could be decisive in a six-month standoff between Syrian security forces and anti-government activists which has seen more than 2,700 civilian deaths and sharply destablised the region.

    Erdogan is preparing for a range of economic, military and political sanctions which will further damage the once-close relationship between the two states.

    After playing a backseat role during the first months of uprising in Syria, Turkey has taken centre stage. Some observers believe Turkey is potentially the most influencial regional player to emerge in the crisis.

    “The reassessment on the Turkish side was because the formal policy of ‘zero problem with the neighbours’ was coming to an end as a result of the Arab Spring,” said Sinan Ulgen, a visiting scholar at international diplomacy organisation Carnegie Europe. “Turkey was somewhat late in making that evaluation, on Libya for example.

    “Turkish policy makers realised that [the policy] could no longer stand because it boiled down to ‘zero problem’ with the regimes. The government could no longer showcase Syria as a shining example of political success. From that point the policymakers took a decision to be on the right side of history and be much more supportive of the pro-democracy movements in these countries.”

    As the Syrian uprising gathered pace in March, Erdogan and his government were reluctant to criticise the actions of the regime’s security forces. Turkey’s foreign minister twice met with Assad and Erdogan spoke with the Syrian leader several times by phone.

    “He believed that he had Assad’s word,” said a source close to the Turkish leader. “Then it became clear that everything he said he was not honouring.””There was built up frustration in Ankara at the stubbornness of the regime in Damascus,” Ulgen said. “The Government believed that they had established such a strong relationship with Assad, that they would be able to nudge the government in a certain direction.”

    The dramatic deterioration in relations between Assad and Erdogan has led to speculation that Syria may use the Kurdish minority in the north of the country to agitate Ankara. The PKK, a Kurdish group regarded by Ankara as a terrorist organisation, has strong support among the Kurds of Syria. The Turkish military fears Syrian officials may try to spark conflict.

    “It has happened once before 10 years ago,” said a Turkish official. “We will watch closely to see what they do this time.”

    Ulgen added: “There is speculation that … the PKK card [will] be played against Turkey,” said Ulgen.

    There is also speculation that Turkey may establish a buffer zone inside its border, or inside Syria if fighting in northern areas continues. But Ulgen downplayed such talk. “It is politically very unlikely as things stand,” he said. “The only scenario for this to become possible is if there is a resurgence in the atrocities that lead to a big refugee movement again.”

    Turkey continues to host senior members of Syria’s nascent opposition movement and defectors from the military. It is understood to be working with the United States on moves to improve organisation of the oppsotion, but insists no military support is being provided.”The next month will be very important in all of this,” said the Turkish offiical.

    Ulgen agreed. “The deficit of trust is so big … things can never return.”

    via Turkey to press ahead with sanctions against Syria | World news | The Guardian.

  • Turkey Slaps Arms Embargo on Syria

    Turkey Slaps Arms Embargo on Syria

    By AP / SELCAN HACAOGLU Saturday, Sept. 24, 2011

    (ANKARA, Turkey) — Turkey on Friday slapped an arms embargo against Syria for its brutal crackdown on the country’s uprising, the prime minister said.

    Recep Tayyip Erdogan said Turkey has stopped a Syrian-flagged ship in the Sea of Marmara in the past, the state-run Anatolia news agency reported. He did not say when the ship was stopped or whether any weapons were found aboard it. “If there are planes carrying weapons, or such shipments by land, then we would stop and confiscate them as in the past,” the Anatolia quoted Erdogan as saying. (See pictures of the formerly-cordial Syria/Turkey relationship.)

    Turkey intercepted an arms shipment from Iran to Syria in August. In March, Turkish authorities also seized the cargo of an Iranian plane bound for Syria because the shipment violated U.N. sanctions. Turkish media said the aircraft was carrying light weapons, including automatic rifles, rocket launchers and mortars.

    Erdogan said this week that Turkey was coordinating its efforts with the U.S. Washington has called on Syrian President Bashar Assad to resign and imposed sanctions on some Syrian officials, blocked assets they may have in the U.S. and banned any U.S. import of Syrian oil or petroleum products. Erdogan told Turkish journalists after talks with President Barack Obama in New York late Tuesday that he was no longer in contact with Syria’s leadership. “I have cut all contacts with the Syrian administration,” Erdogan said. “We never wanted things to arrive at this point, but unfortunately, the Syrian administration has forced us to take such a decision.”

    Turkey is Syria’s neighbor and an important trade partner and Erdogan had cultivated a close friendship with Assad. But Turkish leaders have grown increasingly frustrated with Damascus over its refusal to halt the crackdown on opposition protesters and to carry out reforms. Earlier this month, Turkey hosted a group of Syrian opposition figures who declared a 140-member Syrian National Council in an effort to present a united front against President Bashir Assad. About 7,500 Syrians are seeking refuge from the violence in six camps in Turkey, near the border.

    via Turkey Slaps Arms Embargo on Syria – TIME.

  • Turkey may join US in sanctions against Syria

    Turkey may join US in sanctions against Syria

    BON VILLELABEITIA

    Published: 2011/09/22 09:11:58 AM

    TURKEY has suspended talks with Syria and may impose sanctions, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said yesterday — the clearest sign yet Turkey has parted ways with President Bashar al-Assad over his crackdown on antigovernment protesters.

    After long maintaining close relations with neighbour Syria, Turkey has spoken out increasingly against Mr al-Assad. Mr Erdogan said last week that Turkey’s approach to Syria had changed and it would announce its “final” decision by the time of the United Nations General Assembly meeting in New York.

    “I halted talks with the Syrian government. I did not want to come to this point. But the Syrian government forced us to make such a decision,” Mr Erdogan told Turkish journalists in New York yesterday after meeting US President Barack Obama on the sidelines of the General Assembly.

    “The US has sanctions regarding Syria. Our foreign ministers will be working together to decide what our sanctions may be. ” He said the santions “may not resemble those on Libya. Every sanction differs according to country, people and demographic structure.”

    Mr al-Assad’s attempt to stamp out dissent by having troops and tanks assault restive areas has led the US and European Union to gradually escalate economic sanctions.

    Turkey, which has been Syria’s main trading partner, had resisted sanctions after suffering the effects of past sanctions imposed on Iraq during Saddam Hussein’s rule and now on Iran, another neighbour.

    Bilateral trade between Turkey and Syria was $2,5bn last year, up from $500m in 2004.

    Turkey is one of the few countries in the world that has had open communication lines with Damascus.

    Separately, Syria accused Israel yesterday of posing a threat to the world with its “huge military nuclear arsenal”, a day after the Jewish state criticised Damascus for stonewalling a United Nations watchdog investigation into its atomic activities. The exchange, at a UN nuclear agency meeting, underlined deep divisions between Arab states and Israel. Reuters

    via BusinessDay – Turkey may join US in sanctions against Syria.

  • Sport overcomes politics as Turkey hosts Israelis amid rising tensions

    Sport overcomes politics as Turkey hosts Israelis amid rising tensions

    By Ben Hartman, for CNN
    September 22, 2011 — Updated 1159 GMT (1959 HKT)

    110921022507 besiktas carsi tattoo horizontal gallery
    A Besiktas fan shows a tattoo which reads “Carsi” — the name of the club’s most famous supporters’ club.

    STORY HIGHLIGHTS
    • Clash between football teams from Turkey and Israeli passes peacefully in Istanbul
    • There had been fears that Maccabi Tel Aviv’s players and fans would be attacked
    • Besiktas supporters insist they have no problem with Israelis, but wanted to win
    • Just a dozen Maccabi fans attended the match, played amid rising political tension

    Istanbul, Turkey (CNN) — They traveled to Istanbul amid fears that mob violence might erupt as relations between two once-friendly nations turned ugly.

    But if Maccabi Tel Aviv and the Israeli club’s supporters received any trouble from the people of Turkey last week, it was only on the football pitch.

    After a 5-1 trouncing at the hands of Istanbul’s Besiktas, Maccabi safely returned to Tel Aviv the next day as concerns that the team and its fans would be in danger proved unfounded.

    The Europa League match appeared to be a perfect convergence of sports and politics, coming as relations between Israel and Turkey reached an all-time low.

    Less than two weeks before the match, Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan expelled the Israeli ambassador over the Middle Eastern country’s refusal to apologize for a naval commando raid on the SS Mavi Marmara, on which nine Turkish activists were killed as they made their way to the blockaded Gaza Strip.

    Days later, Turkey broke off military ties with Israel — and Jerusalem announced the formation of a naval alliance with Greece, Turkey’s historical enemy.

    Erdogan has since threatened to deploy Turkish warships to escort the next Gaza Flotilla and to increase Turkish naval presence in the Eastern Mediterranean to counter Israeli “bullying practices” in the area.

    Turkey quickly became a state where Israelis no longer feel welcome, just as Maccabi Tel Aviv headed to Istanbul for a match against a team renowned for having some of the wildest fans in Turkish soccer.

    Elif Batuman, a regular contributor to The New Yorker and a writer-in-residence at Koc University, described the Besiktas squad as “the more working-class team.”

    “Of the three main Istanbul teams, Besiktas is kind of the underdog. They have the least money, the most run-down stadium,” she said.

    “With the other two big Istanbul teams (Galatasaray and Fenerbahce), the stadiums don’t have any particular ties to their neighborhoods, and the fan bases are more spread out. They call themselves the neighborhood team, the people’s team.”

    Ahead of a talk on Turkish soccer at an art gallery in central Istanbul the day before the match, Batuman described Besiktas supporters as being tied not only to the neighborhood but also, to some extent, to a political way of life.

    Israel isn’t our problem, it’s the country’s problem. Every Besiktas game is crazy
    Kemal Yuksel

    “They’re the most political of the soccer teams: they support Greenpeace, they do blood drives, they’re environmentalists. They’re definitely not pro-American, the ones I’ve talked to, but they say they don’t dislike Americans, only American policy. They are also definitely not pro-Israel and they support the Palestinians.”

    He said the match against Maccabi, the most successful club in Israel, was “clearly seen as a rallying event.”

    The Israeli media aired reports that Maccabi players who serve in the Israel Defense Forces reserves were banned from taking part in the game out of fear for their safety. The report turned out to be false, but was in keeping with a general sense in Israel that the team was heading straight into the lion’s den at the worst possible moment, prompting calls for the game to be canceled or forfeited.

    By mid-afternoon on Thursday, Besiktas fans began pouring into a square in the heart of their neighborhood, a short walk from the stadium. Cheering and downing copious amounts of Efes Pilsen beer, they locked arms and sang about the evils of the hated Fenerbahce and the beauty of all that is Besiktas.

    Those Besiktas supporters spoken to at the pre-game drink-up did not appear to have the Gaza Strip or the Mavi Marmara on their minds, and were completely indifferent to the presence of an Israeli reporter scribbling on a notepad in their midst.

    They’re the most political of the soccer teams: they support Greenpeace, they do blood drives, they’re environmentalists
    Elif Batuman on Besiktas fans

    “We hate Fenerbahce, not Israel,” said Kazim, a student from Yildiz Technical University in Istanbul, who also said he did not believe the war of words between the Turkish PM and Netanyahu gave the game any extra meaning.

    Kemal Yuksel, a student at the Istanbul Technical University said the Besiktas fans are “just interested in football, not politics.”

    “We live for Besiktas and it doesn’t matter what country you’re from — we want to beat you,” he said. “Israel isn’t our problem, it’s the country’s problem. Every Besiktas game is crazy, doesn’t matter if we play Maccabi or anyone else.”

    At the same time that the Besiktas fans were pounding pre-game lagers, a crowd of around 200 people marched from Taksim Square in central Istanbul to the Inonu stadium, vowing not to forget or forgive the Mavi Marmara incident. Wearing t-shirts emblazoned with the pictures of the nine Turkish activists and with some protesters carrying flags of the Lebanese Shi’ite militia Hezbollah, they made their way towards the stadium without arrest or incident.

    The protest was a repeat of sorts of a smaller gathering held the night before outside the Divan hotel where the Maccabi players were staying. A crowd of about 20 people waving Palestinian flags stood in silence across from the hotel for a couple of hours before filing away into the night.

    Meanwhile, a block further down the street past the Divan hotel, three street-walkers of unclear gender plied their wares, drawing slightly more interest from passersby than the nearby anti-Israel protest.

    We told everyone we were Israeli. No-one gave us any trouble whatsoever
    Israel Mukhtar

    Like everywhere else the Maccabi players traveled during their visit, the Divan was under heavy police protection. Outside the hotel, two armored police vans were parked at the ready, with officers in front of the vehicles with sub-machine guns. Around a dozen other police officers stood in formation next to the vans, but were not wearing riot gear. Next to the vehicles, a police sedan idled, while a single officer napped in the front seat.

    The heightened security continued inside the stadium, where dozens of riot police circled the field and plainclothes police and security officials kept a constant watch on the event.

    Once the match kicked off, it took only three minutes for Besiktas forward Hugo Almeida to put his team on the board with the first of his two goals. Maccabi answered soon after halftime through forward Roi Kehane, but the visitors never threatened again and Besiktas rolled to a 5-1 victory before a raucous home crowd.

    The 12 hardy Maccabi Tel Aviv fans who attended the game, protected by at least 20 police per head, were seated in the fenced-off visitors’ section, which was book-ended on the left and right by two sections of empty seats patrolled by stadium security.

    One of those Israeli fans who made the trip to Istanbul was Israel Mukhtar, 45, who was in town on his first-ever trip abroad with the Maccabi squad.

    “We went all around the markets and the nightclubs [in Istanbul] and we told everyone we were Israeli. No-one gave us any trouble whatsoever,” Mukhtar said, adding “all of the security was well done and we never felt a threat for a second, I didn’t even see a single Palestinian flag.”

    Mukhtar and his friends, nearly all of whom were middle-aged men who seemed to know each other prior to the trip, said the danger inherent in the match was overblown by the Israeli media.

    They praised the professionalism of Turkish security forces, and expressed their feelings that the diplomatic tension between the two countries is on the upper levels of their respective government, and not reflected in a visceral hatred from people on the streets of Turkey’s largest city — as opposed to Cairo, for instance, where a mob ransacked the embassy a week earlier forcing the Israeli staff to flee in drag under evacuation by Egyptian commandos.

    Even with the final score of the match reflecting an on-field massacre of the Israeli visitors, Mukhtar said he was not disappointed by his decision to attend the match.

    “To be honest, it made me proud to be Israeli. To know that out of 6 million people (in Israel), you’re one of only 12 who was willing to come … I think it means something.”

    Ben Hartman is a reporter for the Jerusalem Post.