Category: Israel

  • Danger Middle East may yet ‘go ballistic’

    Danger Middle East may yet ‘go ballistic’

    davidpratt1IN more than two decades of Middle East watching, I’ve got used to unexpected events and endless predictions of doomsday scenarios.

     

    But, even by its own politically volatile and labyrinthine standards, there have been some very ominous and shadowy things taking place there of late.

     

    Doubters of course might argue that what I’m about to say is only being alarmist and that we’ve been here before. But such a take just doesn’t wash. Recently within the region the implications of both words and deeds have been mind boggling.

     

    Indeed, I’d even go so far as to say that, cumulatively, much of what has been said and done lately displays the potential to merge into the kind of perfect storm of violence and instability rarely before witnessed in the Middle East.

     

    Where to begin, though, when trying to weigh this up? Well, let me first flag up just a few of the dangerous components in this regional timebomb before looking at the mechanisms that in some cases inextricably link them.

     

    To start with, every day that passes indicates a full-scale civil war is emerging in Syria. While many of the stories surfacing from the country are independently difficult to verify, should Wednesday’s attack on an air force intelligence complex near Damascus indeed prove to have been the work of defecting soldiers calling themselves the Free Syrian Army, then the political struggle there has escalated into a new and intensified phase. It is, of course, still early days in terms of writing off President Bashar al Assad.

     

    That said, there are now clear indications of the opposition beginning to wage a co-ordinated insurgency against his Alawite regime, and Syria’s suspension from the Arab League along with other international diplomatic pressure would suggest the president’s days are numbered. This growing regional consensus should be seen for what it is; the product of a rapidly changing geopolitical dynamic across the Middle East and a dangerous one at that.

     

    With the United States nearing its year-end withdrawal of forces from Iraq, Washington and its allies know all too well that Iran is poised to fill the power vacuum in this predominantly Shi’ite Muslim nation. For Tehran it stands as a perfect opportunity to consolidate Shi’ite influence extending from Iraq to Syria, where al Assad’s regime and Hizbollah in neighbouring Lebanon have long provided Tehran with a base from which to threaten Israel.

     

    If the al Assad regime should fall and Syria be returned to Sunni power, however, no doubt many of the region’s key players – Saudi Arabia, Turkey and the United States among them – would breath a sigh of relief over Iran’s loss of influence and ability to arm and fund its militant proxies like Hizbollah in Lebanon and Hamas in the Palestinian Territories. Put another way, if Iran can’t be controlled in Iraq, then a return of a Sunni regime to Damascus would at least clip its wings in Syria.

     

    And, speaking of clipping Iran’s wings, brings me to the second potentially incendiary component currently threatening the region’s stability – Tehran’s nuclear programme. For some time now alarm bells have been ringing in Israel over Iran’s capacity to develop atomic weapons. Those concerns appear to have been borne out by recent reports from the International Atomic Energy Authority (IAEA).

     

    Certainly there are some within the Israeli political and military establishment who, if they had their way, would have already neutralised that threat by whatever means necessary, including a pre-emptive military strike against Iran’s uranium enrichment programme and missile installations. To that end, some observers say a covert war of “black ops” has for some time been waged against Iran.

     

    The assassinations of Iranian nuclear scientists on the streets of Tehran, the Stuxnet Worm computer virus cyber attacks and its recent successor which goes by the name of Duqu that have played havoc with Iran’s nuclear enrichment centrifuges, all point to the fact that someone, somewhere, is determined to deprive Iran of a nuclear weapons arsenal.

     

    Recently, though, the ante has well and truly been upped. Last week a huge explosion at an Iranian Revolutionary Guard base killed Major General Hassan Moghaddam and 16 others. Major Moghaddam was generally seen as the “godfather” of Iran’s missile programme, which has deployed ballistic missiles with ranges of up to 1500 miles –enough to reach Europe.

     

    While Tehran has long insisted the Israeli intelligence service Mossad, or the CIA, have been behind such things, both Jerusalem and Washington have remained schtum. That said, there were some curious remarks in the aftermath of the blast when Israeli Defence Minister Ehud Barak commented that, while he didn’t know the extent of the explosion, “it would be desirable if they multiplied”.

     

    Curiously, too, around the same time as the blast near the Tehran base, elsewhere in the region – Dubai to be precise – another Iranian, Ahmed Rezaie, the son of a high-ranking Tehran official Mohsen Rezaie, secretary of the powerful Expediency Council and former Revolutionary Guards commander, was found dead in the city’s Gloria Hotel. Mystery surrounds the specific circumstances of his death. Even Israeli sources, however, admit the method used to kill him strongly resembled those used in January last year in another Dubai hotel to assassinate Mahmoud al Mabhouh, a Palestinian official who was seen as Hamas’s contact man with Tehran. A murder that many believe was the work of Mossad despite Israeli denials.

     

    As was evident on that occasion, last week’s slaying of Rezaie revealed little signs of violence on the body and according to some sources the Iranian had been injected with a muscle relaxant called Suxamethonium before being smothered with a pillow.

     

    Like pieces in a complex political jigsaw puzzle, all these events – from civil war in Damascus, to bomb blasts in Tehran and murders in Dubai – point to a new and bitter tussle for power across the Middle East that is being executed and perpetrated both openly and covertly. On one level it is a struggle for dominance between Sunni and Shia, between Saudi Arabia and Iran. On another, it is about containing Iranian political and military ambitions and protecting Israel and US interests across the region.

     

    What is most worrying about all of this is both its direction and momentum are unpredictable and the stakes immeasurably high.

     

    One can only begin to imagine, for example, what the simultaneous effects of Syria imploding into civil war and an Israeli military strike against Iran would mean not just for the region but globally.

     

    So many factors could now ignite the blue touch paper and standing well back would be a near impossible option for the international community. The Middle East might just be about to go ballistic, and I’m not simply talking about a few missiles in Iran.

     

    www.heraldscotland.com, 18 Nov 2011

     

  • Pulp Friction: Israel and Turkey

    Pulp Friction: Israel and Turkey

    By Ali Nuri Bayar and Mikhaila Fogel

    The long-standing friendship between Turkey and Israel seemed once to offer testament to the idea that Arab-Israeli Conflict based not on religion or ethnicity, but on solvable political difference. Since 1949, when Turkey became the first Muslim nation to establish relations with Israel, the two counties have created a beneficial partnership. Yet sixty years of cooperation appear to have been obliterated in the past three short years, as relations between Ankara and Jerusalem chill by the day. Nonetheless, current tensions largely reflect shifting geopolitical forces in the region, rather than ideological divisions. The driver of Turkey and Israel’s split remains the separation between Turkey’s new stature in the Middle East and Israel’s growing isolation in the region.

    The Good Old-ish Days

    Beginning with the election of Justice and Development Party in 2002, Israel and Turkey enjoyed a period of unprecedented diplomatic cooperation and economic exchange. Excluding revenues from natural gas and petroleum products, Turkey’s trade agreements with Iran amounted to $2 billion in 2011, while its trade agreements with Israel amount to over $4 billion. Shimon Peres enjoyed several visits to Ankara, Prime Minister Tayyip Erodgan to Israel, and the countries have exchanged hundreds of thousands of tourists every year.

    Erodgan’s reaction to the Gaza War of 2008-2009 catalyzed a break in the quasi-alliance between the two nations. In the so-called “One Minute Scandal” at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Erodgan offered a series of inflammatory remarks regarding the Gaza War, and ignited a verbal sparring match between the two nations. The conflict culminated in diplomatic debacle, in which the Turkish Ambassador to Israel was asked to sit in a lower chair than his Israeli counterparts. Although Israel apologized for the insult, residual resentment lingers in Turkey. A major turning point occurred on May 30, 2010 when nine Turkish activists were killed aboard the Mavi Marmara, a ship attempting to break the Israeli blockade of Gaza.

    Controversy over the flotilla continues to sour relations. Turkey demands a formal apology and compensation for the families of the deceased, while Israel defends the legitimacy of its actions. In September, the United Nations’ Palmer Commission released a report declaring that, although Israel used excessive force in the Mavi Marmara raid, its blockade of Gaza is legally justified. The day after the release of the Palmer Report, Turkey expelled the Israeli ambassador and suspended all military agreements.

    The New Middle East

    Despite these diplomatic disputes, the most important factors reshaping the Israel-Turkey relationship may not be these incidents, but rather the unprecedented transition in the Middle East. The revolutionary fervor of the Arab Spring has shifted the balance of power in the region, causing Western influence and regional authoritarianism to fall out, and enabled the ascent of a new order of Arab states, embracing democracy and religious expression.

    The effects of Arab Spring have purchased for Turkey a new role in the region. “We are there to set a model that market-economy, democracy, and local cultural values can interact in a positive way,” a Turkish diplomat told the HPR. Prime Minister Erodgan has emerged as a model for the new Arab leaders, and Turkey as the template for secular Islamic democracy. With the falls of Mubarak, Qaddafi, and Hussein, a severely weakened Assad, and diminishing American influence in the Middle East, Turkey has become the standard-bearer of sound governing in the region. While Turkey strives to maintain its traditional domestic policies, its foreign policy has become more active in taking advantage of a distinct power vacuum.

    Israel in Isolation

    On the other hand, Israel’s position has become weaker and more isolated as popular revolutions overturn regional allies. Dr. Charles Freilich, former Israeli Deputy National Security Advisor and Kennedy School fellow, pointed out that Israelis enjoyed “a strong emotion attachment” to the alliance with Turkey, precisely because it proved Israel’s conflict was based in politics, not ideology. The sudden breakdown of relations has led many to reject this optimistic belief and “feel betrayed” by Turkey. This feeling of betrayal has led to a backlash against Arab states and pushed the Israeli government under Benjamin Netanyahu further to the right. Uncertainty has created an impasse between the Turkish and Israeli governments, polarizing both sides further. With Turkey’s increasingly belligerent tone and Israel’s continuation of settlement construction and military operations around the Gaza Strip, prospects for reconciliation are fading at an alarming rate.

    Neither does reconciliation appear on any near horizon. According to a senior Turkish official, if Turkey’s demand for an apology for the flotilla had been met, Turkey would not have expelled the Israeli Ambassador, and the nations could have normalized relations. Yet, Itamar Rabinovich, President of Tel-Aviv University and former Israeli ambassador to the U.S., believes that an apology would not have made any significant diplomatic difference. Rabinovich argues that Turkey deliberately chose to distance itself from Israel in order to boost its standing in the Middle East.

    Transition

    The series of unfortunate events between Israel and Turkey has brought simmering tensions in regional relations to a boil. After repeated rejection from European Union membership, Turkey turned its attention back to the East, through increasing trade with its Muslim neighbors and increasing its advocacy for Palestinian statehood. Yet it would be too much to say that Turkey is shifting its axis and severing its ties with the West. Since the creation of NATO, Turkey has served as a poster child for Middle Eastern democracy, and continues to fulfill its duties as a central regional ally. Yet the Arab Spring and Turkey’s tradition of secular success means that Turkey faces a transition, from being bridge between two continents, to being a leader in its own right. This shift means that Turkey’s decisions will not be based on currying favor with any bloc, but rather focused on expanding its influence. As such, while revolutionaries in Egypt and Tunisia look to Turkey as a leader, Iran is threatening to cancel vital trade agreements with Turkey because of its NATO Early Detection missile defense systems and Turkey’s threat to sanction Syria.

    A Turkish official told the HPR, “[Turkey wants] a stable, secure, and prosperous Middle East”. Yet neither stability nor prosperity can be achieved without collaboration between Israel and Turkey. Collaboration existed for sixty years, proving that political shifts, not enduring ideology, have caused the present rift. If these two nations wish to be leaders of a secure region, they must be prepared to compromise, with the understanding that the Arab Spring has reshaped their geopolitical calculations.

    Ali Nuri Bayar ‘15 and Mikhaila Fogel ’15 are Contributing Writers

    World — November 11, 2011 8:39 pm

    Pulp Friction: Israel and Turkey

  • Sarkozy calls Netanyahu ‘liar’

    Sarkozy calls Netanyahu ‘liar’

    sarko the mossad agent2

    Lost in Translation?

    Microphones accidently left on after G20 meeting pick up private conversation between US, French presidents. Sarkozy admits he ‘can’t stand’ Israeli premier. Obama: You’re fed up with him? I have to deal with him every day!

    French President Nicolas Sarkozy reportedly told US President 
    Barack Obama that he could not "stand" Prime Minister Benjamin 
    Netanyahu and that he thinks the Israeli premier "is a liar."
    
    According to a Monday report in the French website "Arret sur 
    Images," after facing reporters for a G20 press conference on 
    Thursday, the two presidents retired to a private room, to 
    further discuss the matters of the day.
    
    The conversation apparently began with President Obama criticizing 
    Sarkozy for not having warned him that France would be voting 
    in favor of the Palestinian membership bid in UNESCO despite 
    Washington's strong objection to the move.
    
    The conversation then drifted to Netanyahu, at which time 
    Sarkozy declared: "I cannot stand him. He is a liar." According 
    to the report, Obama replied: "You're fed up with him, but I 
    have to deal with him every day!"
    
    The remark was naturally meant to be said in confidence, but 
    the two leaders' microphones were accidently left on, making 
    the would-be private comment embarrassingly public.
    
    The communication faux pas went unnoticed for several minutes, 
    during which the conversation between the two heads of state – 
    which quickly reverted to other matters – was all but open 
    to members the press, who were still in possession of headsets 
    provided by the Elysée for the sake of simultaneous translation 
    during the G20 press conference.
    
    Arret sur Images 
    "By the time the (media) services at the Elysée realize it, 
    it was on for at least three minutes," one journalist told 
    the website. Still, he said that reporters "did not have a 
    chance to take advantage of this fluke."
    
    The surprising lack of coverage may be explained by a report 
    alleging that journalists present at the event were requested 
    to sign an agreement to keep mum on the embarrassing comments. 
    A Reuters reporter was among the journalists present and can 
    confirm the veracity of the comments.
    
    A member of the media confirmed Monday that "there were discussions 
    between journalists and they agreed not to publish the comments 
    due to the sensitivity of the issue."
    
    He added that while it was annoying to have to refrain from 
    publishing the information, the journalists are subject to 
    precise rules of conduct.
    
    www.ynetnews.com, 07.11.2011
  • Turkey warns Israel against ‘threatening’ gas proprietorship

    Turkey warns Israel against ‘threatening’ gas proprietorship

    Ankara says will not stand for Israel-Cyprus independent gas exploration in east Mediterranean

    Ynet

    Published: 11.05.11, 18:56 / Israel Business

    asda wh

    Ankara will not allow for any independent natural gas exploration projects in the east Mediterranean, Turkey’s Minister of Transport, Maritime and Communications Binali Yildirim told the Turkish Daily Hurriyet on Saturday.

    Yildirim’s statement followed a comment made by President Shimon Peres, who – while on a State visit to Cyprus – lauded Israel’s joint gas exploration projects with Cyprus.

    Turkey will not stand for any “threats” by Israel over its proprietary interests, he said: “The Turkish ‘road map’ on the matter is clear… No project will be allowed to take place without Turkey’s consent.”

    Much of Peres’ visit to Nicosia focused on Israel and Cyprus’ collaborations in the field of maritime gas exploration. But the matter is at the heart of growing tensions between Turkey and Cyprus.

    Ankara and Nicosia have launched UN-brokered negotiations to try and resolve the gas rights dispute.

    The Cypriot government is under contract with Noble Energy, which is partially owend by Israeli businessman Yitzhak Tshuva. Cyprus is set to hold gas explorations in an area bordering Israel’s territorial waters, where a vast depository of natural gas is believed to exist.

    The area is adjacent to the Levitan offshore rig.

    Israel and Cyprus have recently signed a new cooperation agreement in the field of energy development, exploration and conservation.

    via Turkey warns Israel against ‘threatening’ gas proprietorship – Israel Business, Ynetnews.

  • Israel boards protest boats taking medical aid to Gaza

    Israel boards protest boats taking medical aid to Gaza

    The Israeli navy has intercepted and boarded two boats which were trying to break the blockade of the Gaza Strip.

    56482496 013279381 2The Canadian and Irish boats with 27 activists from the US and eight other countries on board had set sail from Turkey on Wednesday.

    They were carrying medical supplies for the coastal enclave.

    The navy said no-one was hurt in the operation and the boats would be towed to the Israeli port of Ashdod, north-east of Gaza.

    The Irish Saoirse (Gaelic for freedom) and the Canadian Tahrir (Arabic for liberation) were about 50 nautical miles from the Gaza shoreline when they were contacted by the Israeli navy and told to turn back, the flotilla organisers told the AFP news agency.

    The navy said it “advised the vessels that they may turn back at any point, thereby not breaking the maritime security blockade” or could sail to Ashdod or an Egyptian port.

    “The activists refused to co-operate,” AFP quoted the navy as saying.

    ‘Safety ensured’

    The navy ships then approached the boats and boarded them before towing them towards Ashdod.

    “The Israel Navy soldiers operated as planned, and took every precaution necessary to ensure the safety of the activists onboard the vessels as well as themselves,” said the navy.

    Palestinians in Ramallah demonstrate outside UN offices in support of flotilla and lifting of the blockade People in the West Bank have staged protests in support of the Gaza flotilla

    Israeli police spokesman Micky Rosenfeld said the activists would be questioned by police and immigration officials, then returned to their home countries, the Associated Press reports.

    Denis Kosseim, a spokesman for the flotilla based in Montreal, earlier told AFP that all those on board had signed an agreement not to put up any resistance if they were boarded.

    The US had urged the activists not to try to break the blockade. US officials also said Turkey had given assurances it would not send warships to escort the flotilla.

    Ankara had previously threatened to use its navy to escort boats carrying activists and supplies to Gaza.

    Relations between Turkey and Israel reached a crisis 18 months ago, when nine Turkish activists were killed in an Israeli raid on a far larger flotilla as it approached Gaza.

    Israel tightened its blockade on Gaza in 2006. It aims to stop the supply of arms or other items for military use and to put pressure on the Hamas administration in the strip. Israel also controls air and sea access to the territory.

    The importing of all weapons and military materials is banned, along with dual use materials such as fertilisers and certain chemicals.

    There are also strict controls on building materials such as cement and steel cables.

    All exports are banned, though this ruling is occasionally lifted.

    Fishermen may only operate in a strip of water up to three nautical miles from the shore.

    Egypt, which used to help maintain the blockade by closing its border with Gaza, now allows the restricted movement of people.

    However, many types of goods are smuggled though tunnels under the Egypt-Gaza border.

    via BBC News – Israel boards protest boats taking medical aid to Gaza.

  • AFP: Israel’s Peres says gas finds no threat to Turkey

    AFP: Israel’s Peres says gas finds no threat to Turkey

    By Charlie Charalambous (AFP) – 16 hours ago

    Israeli President Shimon Peres (L) shaking hands with Cypriot President Demetris Christofias (AFP/PIO, Christos Avraamides)

    NICOSIA — Visiting Israeli President Shimon Peres said in Cyprus on Thursday that gas finds in the Mediterranean Sea were no threat to Turkey but a positive step for the region.

    “We are going to use the gas the way peaceful and democratic people should use it,” said Peres during an official visit to the eastern Mediterranean island, whose maritime exclusive economic zone borders that of Israel.

    “We are not going to waste it, we are not going to play with it, we are not going to use it for the wrong purposes,” he added.

    In December, Cyprus and Israel signed an agreement defining their maritime border that allows the neighbours to forge ahead in the search for energy resources in the eastern Mediterranean.

    At the end of September, US firm Noble Energy began exploratory drilling for gas off divided Cyprus’s southern coast, ignoring Ankara’s warnings that Turkey would retaliate by launching its own explorations in the area.

    Meanwhile, Turkey’s relations with Israel have worsened since May 2010, when Israeli commandos stormed a convoy of six ships trying to reach the Gaza Strip in defiance of an Israeli naval blockade, killing nine Turkish activists.

    Israel’s closer ties with Cyprus in the energy field have strained relations with Ankara even further.

    But Peres said: “Our discoveries are not against anyone; our discoveries are for the people.”

    “We look upon gas, not as a power, but as an occasion to better the life of the people. We shall do it peacefully.”

    The visit of the veteran Israeli politician and Nobel Prize winner is a landmark in burgeoning Cyprus-Israel relations, which have not always been this amicable.

    Peres said Israel did not want to forge alliances “based on military strengths but seek cooperation based on goodwill.”

    “I never said that we are enemies to the Turks, we are friends with the Turks.”

    Turkey repeatedly called on Cyprus to postpone its gas exploration, saying the Greek Cypriot side has no right to do so while the island remains split, thus leaving the Turkish north out of the picture.

    In retaliation, it sent a ship of its own to carry out explorations, drawing protests from Cyprus.

    Cyprus has been divided along ethnic lines since 1974, when Turkish troops invaded and occupied its northern third in response to an Athens-engineered coup in Nicosia aimed at union with Greece.

    It says its hydrocarbon search is to the benefit of all Cypriots and the island has every right under international law to do so.

    After talks with Peres on Thursday Cyprus President Demetris Christofias said Turkey’s negative reaction was “outside acceptable norms of behaviour.”

    “We are witnessing once again the provocative and aggressive stance of Ankara.”

    The United Nations and Washington have appealed for calm on the issue while the European Union has urged Turkey not to issue threats against member state Cyprus.

    Both the EU and UN are worried that the energy row — which also involves Greece — could derail Cyprus peace talks that are faltering after three years of painstaking negotiations.

    Noble has no exact estimate of the hydrocarbon deposits inside Cyprus’s exclusive economic zone, but has said seismic surveys were “very favourable” indicating a “sizeable quantity.”

    Israeli company Delek is a partner of Noble, which has reported large reserves of natural gas in two Israeli offshore fields.

    Delek and its Texan partner announced the discovery of 16 trillion cubic feet (453 billion cubic metres) of natural gas in the Leviathan gas field some 60 kilometres (40 miles) from Cyprus’s exclusive economic zone. It said to be one of the biggest finds in a decade.

    Gas was also found in Israel’s Tamar block even closer to the Mediterranean island.

    Copyright © 2011 AFP. All rights reserved. More »

    via AFP: Israel’s Peres says gas finds no threat to Turkey.