Category: EU Members

European Council decided to open accession negotiations with Turkey on 17 Dec. 2004

  • Kurdish Assassinations in Paris Put Spotlight on Turkey-PKK Talks

    Kurdish Assassinations in Paris Put Spotlight on Turkey-PKK Talks

    French justice authorities scrambled for clues Thursday into the assassination of three women in a Kurdish institute in Paris — a crime that appeared to have clear political overtones. Two of the victims were shot in the head, in what Interior Minister Manuel Valls said was “no doubt an execution.” One of them was Sakine Cansiz, a co-founder of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK), a group that has waged an often violent Kurdish separatist struggle against Turkey and which has been designated a terrorist organization by the U.S. and the E.U.

    FREDERICK FLORIN / AFP / Getty Images  People attending a demonstration in Strasbourg, France, on Jan. 10, 2013, hold photos of three Kurdish activists killed in Paris  Read more:
    FREDERICK FLORIN / AFP / Getty Images
    People attending a demonstration in Strasbourg, France, on Jan. 10, 2013, hold photos of three Kurdish activists killed in Paris
    Read more: http://world.time.com/2013/01/10/kurdish-assassinations-in-paris-turn-a-spotlight-on-turkey-pkk-talks/#ixzz2HizGJqzZ

    The slayings come at a sensitive time. Turkish media report that the Ankara government has recently made progress toward ending the nearly three decades of violence through unpublicized peace talks with some PKK leaders, included jailed PKK chief Abdullah Ocalan. Such peace talks are not supported by all PKK militants — a strategic division that may have caused a schism within the group.

    (MORE: How the Kurds Have Changed Turkey’s Calculations on Syria)

    Reports on Thursday quoted top Turkish politicians speculating that the Paris murders were a result of “an internal feud” within the PKK. But that claim was rejected by many of the hundreds of Kurds who gathered Thursday morning outside the Kurdish Information Center in Paris where the killings took place; instead, they blamed Ankara.

    “The murder of these three Kurdish women, at this time, is a political crime,” Berivan Akyol, a worker at the center, told French news channel i-télé. “These three victims … represent all Kurds.”

    The deceased had apparently been shot Wednesday afternoon and were discovered around 1 a.m. Thursday after concerned colleagues failed to reach them by phone. In addition to PKK co-founder Cansiz, a woman described as a representative of the Brussels-based Kurdistan National Congress was among the dead. According to the Firat news agency — which is considered sympathetic to the Kurdish cause — two of the women were shot in the head and a third in the stomach by a silencer-fitted gun.

    French security officials tell TIME it’s too early to openly speculate about who was behind the killings, though two obvious theories are already under consideration. Given the brutality with which Turkey has at times sought to suppress Kurdish nationalism and the violent methods sometimes used by the PKK in its struggle for autonomy, French authorities believe that both scenarios — an assassination ordered by the PKK’s enemies or a deadly factional split — are equally plausible.

    (MORE: French Draft Law on Armenian Genocide Rocks Franco-Turkish Relations)

    The first thesis, said a French security official who did not want to be quoted, might aim at weakening PKK factions hostile to negotiating an end to the conflict. The second, he added, might seek to further widen the split between rival PKK camps over peace talks, thereby hampering further efforts in striking a deal with Turkey. But whatever the motive for the killings, Valls pledged to bring to justice those responsible.

    “The antiterrorism and [homicide] units have been mobilized to shed light on this absolutely intolerable act,” Valls said Thursday morning outside the Kurdish center, not far from Paris’ Gare du Nord train station. “I have come to express my compassion for those who are close to these three women.”

    Valls was also addressing the hundreds of sorrowful and angry Kurds who’d flocked to the center early Thursday, chanting Ocalan’s name and “We are all PKK.” About 150,000 Kurds live in France, many as political exiles. Meanwhile, despite the PKK’s terrorist designation, the organization has enjoyed the ambivalent support of many in Europe sympathetic to the Kurdish plight.

    That ambivalence has at times also been reflected by French justice officials. While authorities have repeatedly arrested militants suspected of organizing or financing acts of PKK terrorism, less troublesome party members and sympathizers are generally left alone. The 28-year battle between the PKK and Turkey has claimed about 40,000 lives, with violence at times having spilled into other countries. The chants of “A political solution for Kurdistan” among Kurdish mourners in Paris on Thursday appeared to express hopes that this new trio of deaths in that struggle will be the last.

    via Kurdish Assassinations in Paris Put Spotlight on Turkey-PKK Talks | TIME.com.

  • Turkey’s war hits streets of Paris

    Turkey’s war hits streets of Paris

    Hunt on for killers after three women who supported the Kurdish separatist movement are executed in their office

    John Lichfield

    Paris

    turkeyswar-afp

    The brutal assassination in central Paris of three Kurdish militants, including a founder member of the separatist group the PKK, sent a wave of shock through France and Turkey today.

    The three women were found shot in the head at a Kurdish “information centre” a few steps from the Gare du Nord in the early hours of yesterday morning. The attack is believed to have occurred at least eight hours earlier.

    Police broke down the blood-stained door of office in a classic Parisian apartment block and discovered what one officer called a scene of “cold-blooded butchery, almost certainly an execution”. Two of the women had been shot in the back of the head and the other in the forehead and chest.

    Turkish government officials and French intelligence sources last night blamed faction-fighting  within the PKK (Kurdistan Workers’ Party) for the killings. They said that the murders were probably connected to exploratory talks between the Turkish government and the imprisoned PKK leader, Abdullah Ocalan, which were revealed in the Turkish press on Wednesday. The negotiations were said to have produced a  “road-map” to end the 30-year-old civil war in south-eastern Turkey in which 40,000 people are believed to have died.  One of the victims – and possibly the principal target – was Sakine Cansiz, in her late 50s, a long-time associate of Mr Ocalan and a founder member of the PKK, which was established in 1978.

    In recent years Ms Cansiz had apparently fallen out with the PKK’s splintered leadership, but remained a supporter of the Kurdish separatist cause. Last night President François Hollande said: “This is a horrible crime [involving] three people, one of whom I knew well because she often came to see political leaders [in France].” It is believed that Mr Hollande was referring to Ms Cansiz.

    Police sources told the French media that there was no sign of a break-in, suggesting that the three women may have opened the door to whoever killed them. The other victims were  named as Fidan Dogan, 28, a Brussels-based official of the Kurdistan National Congress (KNK),  a support-group for the PKK, and Leyla Soylemez, 25, who ran a Kurdish youth association in Paris.

    Ms Soylemez’s boyfriend became anxious late on Wednesday night  after she failed to go home answer her mobile. He went to the Kurdish Information Office on the Rue Layafette between the Gare du Nord and the Gare de l’Est and found traces of blood on the outer door. He called police who broke down the first-floor and found the bodies. Detectives believe the women were killed some time between 3pm and 6pm on Wednesday.

    Political assassinations are rare events in Paris or any other Western European capital. The French Interior Minister, Manuel Valls, visited the crime scene this morning. “Three women have been murdered, doubtless executed,” he said. “This is a very serious event… The French authorities will do all in their power to throw light on this completely intolerable act.”

    Tonight there were a number of theories about who was responsible for the attack. Ms Cansiz had been granted political asylum in France after being imprisoned in Turkey, although did not live permanently in Paris. Kurdish officials in Paris dismissed the “internal quarrel” theory, instead blaming agents of the Turkish government or French-based activists in extreme nationalist Turkish right. Once news of the killings had got out more than 300 Kurdish exiles demonstrated and waved Kurdish flags in the rain close to the murder scene. They chanted “Turkey assassins. Hollande is their accomplice,” and “We are all in the PKK.”

    The PKK was founded in 1978 by Mr Ocalan and Ms Cansiz, among others, to campaign for a Marxist Kurdish state in south eastern Turkey and the Kurdish-populated areas of Iran, Iraq and Syria. It began a military campaign in the mid-1980s after repression by the then military junta in Ankara.  It is classed as a terrorist organisation by Turkey, the US and the EU and Mr Ocalan has been in a Turkish jail since 1999.

    According to reports in the Turkish press on Wednesday, the peace talks between Ankara and Mr Ocalan would involve a ceasefire in return for release of prisoners and official recognition of the Kurdish language and culture. Today’s murders, according to the Turkish government and French intelligence sources, may have been intended to discredit or destroy these talks. The PKK has a history of bloody settlement of internal battles, including, allegedly, murders on foreign soil.

    A Turkish political commentator, Emre Uslu, who once worked in Turkey’s counter-terrorism unit, suggested that the killings might have been ordered by the PKK leadership, pointing out that Ms Cansiz led a faction that had opposed Mr Ocalan’s peace moves in the past. But a Kurdish official in Paris, Eyup Doru, dismissed the claims and said that he was convinced that the Turkish government was responsible. “The work [these three women] were doing, attracting attention to repression by the Turkish authorities, doubtless embarrassed the [Ankara] government,” he said.

    This theory was dismissed by French intelligence sources. “It’s difficult to imagine the Turkish state undertaking this kind of operation in France,” an internal security source told the newspaper Le Figaro. “Police and judicial cooperation is one area where Paris and Ankara get on reasonably well.  It is unthinkable, even ridiculous, to believe that this was a Turkish undercover action.” Others pointed out, however, that extreme nationalist Turkish groups were active within the Turkish diaspora in France. The information office had been repeatedly identified by the Turkish community in Paris as a source of recruitment and fund-raising for the PKK.

    The victims: Who was who

    Sakine Cansiz

    As a founding member of the militant Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK), Sakine Cansiz was the first senior female member of the organisation. Cansiz led the Kurdish protest movement out of Turkey’s Diyarbakir prison in the 1980s, and worked with Ocalan in Syria after her release. She later served as a commander of the women’s guerrilla movement in Kurdish areas of northern Iraq.

    According to a US diplomatic cable published by WikiLeaks, Cansiz had been in Paris since she was released from jail in Germany in 2007 – after Berlin turned down a Turkish request for her extradition – and became responsible for the PKK women’s movement in Europe.

    Hurriyet, the Turkish daily newspaper, said Cansiz had been “known for her opposition to the alleged head of the PKK’s armed-wing, Syrian citizen Ferman Hussein”.

    Fidan Dogan

    The 32-year-old Paris representative of the Brussels-based Kurdistan National Congress (KNC) political group worked in the information centre, and was responsible for lobbying European Union diplomats on behalf of the PKK.

    Leyla Soylemez

    Described as a “young activist” for the Kurdistan National Congress, she is believed to have worked on diplomatic relations and as a women’s representative on behalf of the PKK.

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/turkey-s-war-hits-streets-of-paris-8446533.html

  • Turkey condemns killing of Kurdish activists

    Turkey condemns killing of Kurdish activists

    Turkey has condemned the killing of three Kurdish women activists in Paris, calling the murders a “summary execution.”

    France_Kurds_2448398b

    Portraits of presumed victims are seen pinned on a member of the Kurdish community’s coat at they gather next to the entrance of the Information Centre of Kurdistan in Paris.

    Portraits of presumed victims are seen pinned on a member of the Kurdish community’s coat at they gather next to the entrance of the Information Centre of Kurdistan in Paris. Photo: REUTERS

    3:21PM GMT 10 Jan 2013

    Bulent Arinc, a government spokesman, said the deaths were “carried out in the manner of a summary execution”.

    “This is utterly wrong. I express my condolences,” he said.

    His remarks came just hours after three Kurdish women, a co-founder of the outlawed Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) and two other activists, were found shot dead in Paris early on Thursday, in what French authorities labelled an “assassination.”

    Speaking from Senegal, Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said it was “too soon to comment” but the incident could be a “provocation” coming at a time when peace talks between the state and the PKK’s jailed leader Abdullah Ocalan were under way.

    The slayings came as Turkey was holding peace talks with the group to try to persuade it to disarm. A Turkish lawmaker claimed the women were slain in a dispute between PKK factions, while some Kurdish protesters and a Kurdish lawmaker in Turkey claimed the Turkish government was involved.

    Turkey’s Anadolu news agency identified one of the victims as Sakine Cansiz, a founding member of the PKK.

    The conflict between the PKK and Turkish troops has claimed tens of thousands of lives since 1984, when the rebels – who are seeking self-rule for Kurds in southeast Turkey – took up arms.

    Manuel Valls, the French interior minister, who visited the pro-Kurdish centre in Paris where the bodies were found, said the deaths were “without doubt an execution.” He called it a “totally intolerable act.”

    RTL radio reported that all three women were shot in the head, but French police would not immediately confirm the report.

    Emotions mounted as hundreds of Kurds filled the street in Paris outside the Kurdistan Information Center. Police erected barricades to try to contain the crowd. Some people waved Kurdish flags while others chanted angrily against the Turkish government.

    An online site for Kurdish youth called on all Kurds and “friends of Kurds to come to Paris.” The site, jeunessekurde.fr, showed three photos of the slain women. It identified the other two as Fidan Dogan, who reportedly was chief of the information centre, and Leyla Soylemez.

    Kurds make up more than 20 per cent of Turkey’s 75 million people.

    The three women were alone at the centre on Wednesday and were unreachable by telephone, said Leon Edart, an official of the Federation of Kurdish Associations of France.

    In Turkey, Selahattin Demirtas, the leader of a Kurdish political party in Turkey’s parliament, called on the French government to shed light on the killings “without delay” and in a way that “leaves no room” for doubt.

    “We want it to be known that that these assassinations which were carried in the busiest area of Paris cannot be covered up,” Demirtas said.

    Huseyin Celik, the deputy chairman of Turkey’s ruling party, said the attack appeared to be the result of “an internal feud” within the PKK, but did not provide any evidence to back his statement.

    Celik also suggested the slayings were an attempt to derail the peace talks.

    The PKK does have a history of internal executions. While many Kurdish activists and militants were victims of extra-judicial killings blamed on Turkish government forces in the 1990s, it’s not known whether they also targeted any exiled Kurds in Europe.

    In the streets of Paris, the protesters blamed Turkey.

    “Where are French? Where is that solidarity? I think that the state of Turkey did this,” said one man in the Paris crowd, identifying himself only as Ali.

    Turkey frequently accuses, France, Germany and the Netherlands – home to large numbers of Kurds from Turkey – of supporting the PKK, failing to extradite wanted militants and of not backing Turkey’s “fight against terrorism.”

    Turkish officials say the PKK raises funds through extortion or other criminal activities in European countries that have a large number of Kurdish immigrants.

    France has a large Kurdish community concentrated in the Paris region and French police have occasionally arrested Kurds suspected of illegally financing the PKK.

    via Turkey condemns killing of Kurdish activists – Telegraph.

  • Sneijder’s wife: ‘I love Istanbul!’

    Sneijder’s wife: ‘I love Istanbul!’

    Wesley Sneijder’s wife has opened the door for a move to Galatasaray. “Istanbul is definitely nice! Have been there many times, love Turkey!”

    sneijder-yolanthe490ai_1

    This evening Galatasaray released a statement confirming negotiations have formally begun with Inter to sign Sneijder during the January transfer window.

    Initial reports suggest a deal has been agreed with the Nerazzurri worth around €10m, but that the player is unconvinced at what he sees as a step down.

    However, wife Yolanthe Cabau spoke to fans today on Twitter to discuss the new development.

    “Istanbul is definitely nice! Have been there many times, love Turkey!” she wrote when asked about the city.

    “But what will happen, I do not know… I can only say that Wes still loves Inter as much as he did before.”

    via Sneijder’s wife: ‘I love Istanbul!’ | Football Italia.

  • What about Turkey? How the country is fairing with fighting neighbors, failed EU negotiations and the Black Sea.

    What about Turkey? How the country is fairing with fighting neighbors, failed EU negotiations and the Black Sea.

    What about Turkey? How the country is fairing with fighting neighbors, failed EU negotiations and the Black Sea.

    Catherine Stupp | The Christian Science Monitor | Jan 07, 2013

    Its protracted bid to join the European Union remains stalled and its “zero problems” policy in the Middle East is cracking over support for Syria’s opposition. But one foreign policy front retains promise for Turkey: the Black Sea.

    Nowhere is it more evident than the busy industrial city of Trabzon in northeastern Turkey, a regional trade hub because of its location on roads that connect it to both Istanbul and other cities to the east. The cobblestone streets of the city center are bustling with buses and private cars carrying passengers to Georgia, only 125 miles to the northeast, as well as trucks shipping goods across the region via the highway that cuts through the city.

    If plans for a highway connecting the 12 countries bordering the Black Sea go forward, Trabzon’s growth – and Turkey’s growing stance as a regional leader – is poised to surge.

    Turkey’s Black Sea coast, far from its tumultuous southern border, offers a promising contrast its more troubled efforts to join the EU and to expand networks in the Middle East. Ankara has emerged as the dominant initiator of regional cooperation, institutionalized by the Black Sea Economic Cooperation (BSEC), which was founded on the heels of the collapse of the Soviet Union.

    Filling the Soviet vacuum

    Although Turkey was one of 10 founding members, it played a leading role in BSEC’s establishment, and the organization’s permanent headquarters is still located in Istanbul.

    BSEC’s early years were dominated by “Turkey’s initiative to offer these countries an alternative” to their socialist economic systems, says Traian Chebeleu, a former Romanian ambassador and current deputy secretary of BSEC’s transportation activities. In 1992, the same year BSEC was founded, Turkey launched its foreign aid program for developing countries, the Turkish International Cooperation and Development Agency (TIKA), which, in its early phases, focused on assisting the newly independent Central Asian and Caucasus states.

    Today, the Black Sea states are hoping that projects like the Black Sea Ring Highway will further stimulate trade and economic cooperation. Trade within the region rebounded rapidly from a decline in 2009, while trade with the EU recovered at a slower rate. Countries here may be beginning to see interregional outreach as more beneficial than looking outward to their less stable neighbors. While road travel between BSEC states grew at a rate of 40.8 percent between 2007 and 2011, travel between BSEC states and the EU lagged behind somewhat, growing 36.3 percent.

    The highway project is still in development stages, but four lanes of traffic wrapping through 12 countries would be a boon for trade and tourism — or at least that’s what BSEC, the initiator of the project, hopes. The partnership holds both the promise of bolstering existing alliances and testing lingering tensions.

    Trade already booming

    Although BSEC attempts to harmonize trade regulations of its different member states, it’s difficult to measure what direct effects the organization has had on trade within the region.

    For Turkey, the construction project could be the first step in a realignment of its foreign policy. Its northern border along the Black Sea coast is vast, and recent efforts to repair strains between Turkey and Russia suggest that this region is becoming increasingly important for Turkey.

    After Russia, Turkey is the region’s biggest exporter. While Russia and some other BSEC members like Azerbaijan and Ukraine primarily export oil, Turkey’s main exports are textiles and machinery, says Ussal Şahbaz, an economist at The Economic Policy Research Foundation (TEPAV) in Ankara.

    According to Mr. Şahbaz, the ring highway would make transport of goods faster and more efficient. “Over the years maritime transport has declined in relative terms, and railway and highway transport have regained importance. If you ship from China to Europe, it takes 1-1/2 months, whereas if you use highways or railways, it takes 10 days or so.”

    Although BSEC organized the Black Sea Ring Highway Caravan in 2007, a kind of “test run” in which industrial-sized trucks traveled more than 4,660 miles through most member states, not all routes of the ring highway have been built, nor have they been agreed upon.

    The construction of roads is already complete in Turkey and Greece, but the other 10 member states have yet to build their parts of the highway. At the moment, road transport between the Black Sea states is hampered by long waits at border crossings and high fees or other bureaucratic hurdles for truck drivers applying for visas.

    Mr. Chebeleu, the deputy secretary, says that the organization hopes to agree on a time frame for construction by 2014. In his office in the seaside villa that houses the BSEC secretariat, tucked away in the affluent Istanbul neighborhood of Emirgan, Chebeleu talks about the challenge such conflicts pose to their work.

    Regional rivalries

    Russia and Georgia pose the biggest challenge, although the 2008 war between the two has been far from the only hindrance. The war, Chebeleu says, only “added to the problems.”

    Determining a route that can connect the two countries is complicated by territorial disputes. Russia has proposed that the highway pass through Abkhazia, which Russia recognizes as an independent state, but Georgia and the international community consider it Georgian territory. Moldova and Ukraine have had similarly fraught disputes over whether the highway should cut through the disputed area of Transnistria.

    But Chebeleu insists that there is a willingness to find solutions, not only because of the potential economic benefits of BSEC’s projects, but because of the political benefits of economic cooperation for a region dealing with a number of internal conflicts. “Of course it depends on what the member states want, and that nobody interferes in their decisions, but we all want to accept whatever decision they find appropriate for themselves.”

    As a major trade partner for many Black Sea states with comparably smaller economies, Turkey’s participation is critical. The transport route can only directly connect the Caucasus states to the EU and Balkan countries if it runs along Turkey’s northern coast. With the promise a new transportation network along the Black Sea holds for Turkey, its role would seem almost assured, but it is pursuing other avenues for bolstering its regional economic influence as well.

    “While promoting the Black Sea Ring Highway on the one hand, Turkey also endeavors to establish its own transportation network consisting of bilateral units,” extending its regional flight networks and increasing its oversight of marine transportation in the Black Sea, says Selcuk Colakoglu, adviser to the Turkish Ministry of Foreign Affairs’ Center for Strategic Research.

    If ongoing disputes among BSEC members can be quelled and construction of the highway goes forward, Turkey could be well-positioned as the geographic and economic backbone of a lucrative new trade network.

  • Turkey’s EU membership is not a ‘given’: Swedish FM

    Turkey’s EU membership is not a ‘given’: Swedish FM

    IZMIR, Turkey: Turkey’s prospect of joining the European Union at the end of a lengthy process is not a certainty, Sweden’s Foreign Minister Carl Bildt told AFP Sunday, saying efforts would have to be made by both Ankara and Brussels.

    47985_mainimg

    “Nothing is given in the world. Nothing is given in life,” Bildt, a strong advocate of Turkey’s EU bid, said in the western city of Izmir, a day after addressing Turkish ambassadors from around the world during an annual gathering.

    “It requires efforts by both sides. It requires a continued reform process in Turkey, and it requires a continued open attitude by the European Union.”

    Turkey launched formal accession talks with the European bloc in 2005 but they have made little progress because of the quarrel with Cyprus as well as stiff opposition from some EU member states.

    Brussels has opened only 13 of the 35 policy chapters that every state must negotiate in order to join the bloc. Just one chapter has been successfully closed.

    The talks have stalled over problems relating to the ethnic Greek government of EU member Cyprus, a Mediterranean island divided between Greek and Turkish Cypriots, as well as stiff opposition from certain countries including France.

    Bildt hoped that Turkish-EU talks would gain a new momentum in the coming year.

    “I do think that there are positive signs, so we will work on that,” he said.

    As a staunch opponent of Turkey’s EU membership bid, France has blocked five chapters on the grounds that opening them would lead to full membership.

    But the French objections came from former president Nicolas Sarkozy who argued that Turkey was not part of Europe.

    Ankara now expects Paris to lift its veto on the five chapters under Socialist President Francois Hollande, elected in May, who has shown himself to be more open to Turkey’s EU ambitions.

    Turkey’s EU Affairs Minister Egemen Bagis has spoken of mending fences with Paris in a friendly spirit of finding solutions.

    “We are hoping that he (Hollande) would open a new page in the very deep and fruitful historical relations between Turkey and France,” Bagis told AFP back in May.

    For his part Hollande has noted that Turkey would not become an EU member during his five-year term — the road to EU accession is a long one.

    “I think it is too early to tell,” Bildt said when asked if there were signals from France over a policy change.

    “And you will have to wait for the French to state their own position. There are countries where there is opposition but all of the countries are united with the slight exceptions … that we should conclude the negotiations,” he added.

    “And then it will a matter for the final judgement by Turkey and by the European Union at that particular time. But I think concluding the accession negotiations is clearly an interest of both the European Union and Turkey.”

    Turkey is under fire from Brussels for stalling democratic reforms and a lack of sufficient progress in improving its human rights record.

    Ankara however rejects those accusations, and says the EU focuses on shortcomings in the Turkish bid rather than on the reform effort itself.

    Bildt said most of the problems stemmed from Turkey’s “fairly old constitution” made by the junta after the 1980 military takeover.

    He hoped that progress would be made towards the new constitution and the judicial reforms which would address problems.

    Bildt also said he did believe Turkey would join the EU.

    “Yes, I do believe. Don’t ask me when but I do believe it.”

    via Turkey’s EU membership is not a ‘given’: Swedish FM | News , Middle East | THE DAILY STAR.