Category: France

  • Turkey vs. The Louvre: Ankara Renews Its Quest To Recover Antiquities

    Turkey vs. The Louvre: Ankara Renews Its Quest To Recover Antiquities

    ec44a3cc0a2fd16526468304e6b74ee0_turkey

    Reuniting the bust of Hercules with its body was one of the Culture Ministry’s great successes – (Wikimedia / Worldcrunch montage)

    By Guillaume Perrier

    LE MONDE/Worldcrunch

    ISTANBUL – The treasure of Troy is back. The collection of golden jewelry from the ancient city, which had been stolen during the 19th century, was handed back to Turkey by the University of Pennsylvania last September.

    The precious jewelry – known as the “Troy gold” – had been looted after the first excavations of Troy by a German archeologist in the 1870s. No one knows if Helen of Troy actually wore the jewels, but Turkey says it belongs to them. “It is only right that they be returned to where they were taken from,” declared Minister of Culture and Tourism Ertugrul Gunay.

    These jewels are now set to be displayed in Ankara.

    In December, the great Istanbul Archaeology Museum celebrated the return of a mosaic from 194 A.D., depicting Orpheus playing the lyre to calm wild animals. It was stolen in 1998 in Urfa (in ancient times Edessa), near the Syrian border. The mosaic had been auctioned at Christie’s in New York, and bought by the Dallas Art Museum for $85,000.

    With those wonders from Asia Minor (current Turkey) more than 3,700 artifacts – statues, frescos, pots, tools and coins – have been recovered since 2007, thanks to an unprecedented campaign led by the Turkish Ministry of Culture and Tourism.

    The 3,000 year-old Hattusa sphinx, removed from the Hittite imperial city located in the middle of Anatolia, which was on display at Berlin’s Pergamon Museum, also made the trip home recently.

    But the most spectacular restitution was a bust of Hercules, handed back by the Boston Museum of Fine Arts. It was stolen in 1980 on the site of Perga and sold the next year to the American museum. The bust flew back to Turkey on Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s plane – who was returning home after the 2011 UN general assembly.

    “Turkey had been campaigning for the marble’s return for the past two decades,” he declared, triumphant, as he landed in Ankara. The bust of Hercules could finally be reunited with the rest of his body, on display at the Antalya Museum in southwestern Turkey.

    Challenging the museums in court

    The Turkish government’s decades-long struggle to recover stolen artifacts has brought a certain number of museums to their knees. But other museums believe the artifacts belong to them, and are refusing to negotiate. This is the case of Paris’ Louvre Museum, whose Islamic wing holds a wall of Ottoman Iznik ceramic tites that Ankara says were stolen from the Istanbul Piyale Pacha Mosque by a French collector. But the Parisian museum argues the tiles were acquired legally.

    The Louvre also has 16th century ceramic tiles that were taken from Sultan Selim II’s tomb in the Hagia Sophia in Istanbul. However, the UNESCO convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property was signed in 1970 and doesn’t apply to acquisitions made before that date.

    This argument is inconceivable for Murat Suslu, the director of museums for the Turkish Ministry of Culture and Tourism: “What if the Turks came, took a stained glass window from Notre-Dame in the 19th century to renovate it and now refused to give it back?”

    Priam’s treasure remains on display at Moscow’s Pushkin Museum. To get uncooperative countries to hand back their ancient artifacts, Turkey doesn’t hesitate to threaten them with cancelling archeological concessions (especially Germany and France), something these countries call tantamount to blackmail.

    Turkey has also tried going to court to get its artifacts back. An Istanbul lawyer recently filed a claim with the European Court of Human Rights, in a bid to recover statues taken from the Mausoleum of Halicarnassus and currently on display at the British Museum.

    Read the article in the original language.

    Photo by – Wikimedia / Worldcrunch montage

    All rights reserved ©Worldcrunch – in partnership with LE MONDE

    Crunched by: Leo Tilmont

    via Turkey vs. The Louvre: Ankara Renews Its Quest To Recover Antiquities – All News Is Global |.

  • France-Turkey student sentenced on terrorism charges

    France-Turkey student sentenced on terrorism charges

    ANKARA: A court in Turkey on Friday sentenced a French-Turkish student to more than five years in prison for “terrorist propaganda” but allowed her to return to France pending an appeal, her lawyer said.

    The lawyer, Inayet Aksu, said the court in the northwestern city of Bursa had sentenced Sevil Sevimli, 21, to five years and two months in prison but freed her until her planned appeal and did not require that she stay in Turkey. She will however have to pay 10,000 Turkish lira (around 4,200 euros, $5,600) in bail before she leaves, Aksu said.

    The exchange student was arrested after joining a May Day parade in Istanbul and went on trial in September on charges that risked up to 32 years in prison. Aksu said that while she was initially accused of belonging to a terrorist organisation, she was only found guilty of disseminating propaganda on behalf of an outlawed group.

    Sevimli, who was detained for three months before her release under court supervision in August, is accused of links to the Revolutionary People’s Liberation Party-Front (DHKP-C). The far-left extremist group is listed as a terrorist organisation by the United States and the European Union. It claimed responsibility for a suicide bombing at the US embassy in Ankara this month that killed a Turkish security guard.

    Since 1976, the DHKP-C has been behind numerous attacks against the Turkish state that have killed dozens. Sevimli has denied the accusations, calling them “ridiculous”. In November, Aksu told the judge, “Her only fault is to come to Turkey as a student with leftist ideas”.

    Born in France to Turkish Kurd parents, Sevimli was completing a final year of studies in Turkey under Erasmus, the inter-European university exchange scheme, at the time of her arrest. Her friends and supporters greeted the news of her imminent return to France, expected Wednesday, with joy.

    “It’s first off a huge relief to know that Sevil can leave Turkish territory,” said the head of her school in France, Jean-Luc Mayaud of Lyon-2 University.

    via France-Turkey student sentenced on terrorism charges – thenews.com.pk.

  • Turkey Moves Closer to EU Membership Talks

    Turkey Moves Closer to EU Membership Talks

    France on Tuesday said it was ready to resume EU accession talks with Turkey, marking a warming of ties after a long period of bilateral tension under former President Nicolas Sarkozy.

    Speaking at the sidelines of a conference on Libya on Tuesday, French foreign minister Laurent Fabius told his Turkish counterpart Ahmet Davutoglu that Paris is ready to unblock European Union membership talks on the subject of regional policy.

    “I confirmed to him that we were ready … to begin discussions on chapter 22,” Fabius told a news conference. Turkey has completed just one of 35 policy “chapters” every candidate must conclude to join the EU. All but 13 of those chapters are blocked by France, Cyprus and the European Commission.

    Turkey launched a formal EU accession bid in 2005, four decades after the first talks but the process has stalled due to opposition from core EU members France and Germany as well as an intractable dispute over Cyprus, the divided island state that Turkey does not recognise.

    The talks have also been blocked by the European Commission, which says that Turkey does not yet meet the required standards on human rights, freedom of speech and religion.

    “This is certainly a change of attitude from the former government,” said one official in Paris, although he added it was “too early” to tell whether France would now swing fully behind Turkish EU membership – a sharp contrast to Sarkozy’s position that Turkey did not form part of Europe.

    Related Story: While Turkey’s Economic Star Rises, Sarkozy’s France Finds Irrelevance

    Another French diplomatic described it as “a political signal, a first step” to pave the way for French President Francois Hollande to visit Turkey, although no date has been set.

    Despite the slow progress, the eurozone crisis and waning domestic support, Turkey has continued to push for full membership in the EU and has said it wants to join before 2023, the centenary of its founding as a republic.

    Earlier this month, Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan said his country’s half-century wait join the EU was “unforgivable” and it should be admitted without delay.

    Erdogan has previously warned that the EU could “at the very least” lose Turkey if the bloc continues to alienate and give it the cold shoulder and recently raised the possibility of deepening ties with the Russian-Chinese backed Shanghai Co-operation Organisation instead.

    At the end of last year, Ankara accused the EU of “biased and unwarranted bigoted attitudes” in an official report on its membership application process.

    In a statement accompanying the official 270-page report, Turkey’s EU affairs minister Egemen Bagis said:

    Today there is no government in Europe which is more reformist than our government. While EU countries are struggling in crisis, our country is experiencing the most democratic, prosperous, modern and transparent period in its history. The ‘sick man’ of yesterday has got up and summoned the strength to prescribe medication for today’s Europe … and to share the EU’s burden rather than being a burden to it.

    In the decade ending 2012, Turkey recorded the highest-growth rate among the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development economies and is expected to grow 4 percent or more in 2013.

    via Turkey Moves Closer to EU Membership Talks | Economy Watch.

  • Murders in Paris but, Perhaps, Peace in Turkey

    Murders in Paris but, Perhaps, Peace in Turkey

    Posted by Jenna Krajeski
    TURKEY-KURDS-UNREST-FRANCE-CRIME-FUNERALThe Kurdish movement in Turkey works in isolation. Guerillas with the outlawed Kurdistan Workers’ Party (P.K.K.)—which has, for decades, fought the Turkish Army for constitutional rights and autonomy—leave their families for remote posts in the Qandil mountains, on the border between Turkey and Iraq. Hundreds of miles stretch between Istanbul and the politically charged, majority-Kurdish southeast, where economic opportunities are scant compared to western Turkey. Nationalistic media and education on both sides have established an even wider psychological gap. Prisons, where the violent arm of the P.K.K. first came together, continue to hold dissenting Kurds. And, in spite of almost thirty years of armed struggle in a region bordering countries crucial to the political future of the West and the world, Kurds remain largely offstage.

    But recently a few things changed. In Syria, Kurds took control of the northeast, envisioning a future after Assad that includes them. In Iraq, Kurds began managing their own oil deals, defying Baghdad in a push that might transform the de-facto independence of Iraqi Kurdistan into real independence. Turkey, on the heels of a sixty-eight-day hunger strike started by Kurdish prisoners, began new peace talks with Abdullah Ocalan, the imprisoned leader of the P.K.K. Then three Kurdish women were murdered in Paris, shot in the office of the Kurdish Information Center, near the busy Gare du Nord, and the Kurdish issue took on the life of an international murder mystery.

    Whoever shot Sakine Cansiz, Leyla Soylemez, and Fidan Dogan in the office that day used a silencer, a fitting symbol for what is assumed to be the killer’s motive: an end to the talks between Ocalan and the Turkish government. Who did it was less clear. Was it nationalistic Turks? Iranians? A rival Kurd? A few days ago, French authorities arrested Omer Guney, a thirty-year-old Kurd who had worked as Cansiz’s driver, and who has reportedly claimed to be a member of the P.K.K. The arrest has had a calming effect on Turkish politicians, like Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who said that anyone who thought the Turkish state was responsible for the murders “will be ashamed and will apologize when the incident comes to light.”

    French authorities continue to investigate Guney, who, they say, was in the office around the time of the murders, and the case is not yet closed. The response from the Kurdish side—including statements from the P.K.K., which denies that Guney was a member—are in direct opposition to Erdogan’s confident tone.

    But even if no one is ever convicted of pulling the trigger that day in Paris, the murders are an important moment in Kurdish-Turkish relations, carrying the issue across oceans, and clarifying a few key components along the way.

    People in Turkey want the war to stop, but the murders could still have halted the negotiations. “We know that whenever such a process starts, there are spoilers,” said Kerim Yildiz, the director of the U.K.-based Democratic Progress Institute, and himself a Kurd living in Europe. “But this is an extremely positive step that must be supported by everyone.” Unlike in the past, the pro-Kurdish Peace and Democracy Party (B.D.P.) was directly involved and the talks have been made public. Selahattin Demirtas, the co-chair of the B.D.P., whom I reached through D. Dogan, a Kurdish human-rights activist, has been adamant that talks continue, even in the wake of the murders and even though the arrest may expose a rift among members of the P.K.K. “Previous meetings were also being conducted by the government, but they were discreet and mostly conducted in secret,” he wrote to me. “In previous processes the government made serious efforts to prevent any leaks of information, holding off details. This time it was made public by the prime minister himself.”

    The Kurdish issue is an international one. Kurds themselves are spread among Turkey, Iraq, Iran, and Syria, as well as a large diaspora community, of which the three murdered women were a part. The Kurdish Institute in Paris estimates the number of Kurds in Western Europe to be close to a million. Kurds in exile import the politics of home. Cansiz, Soylemez, and Dogan worked as lobbyists on behalf of Kurdish rights; Dogan was the Paris representative for the Brussels-based Kurdish National Congress. On the surface, such work so far from Qandil would seem safe, but the duration and intensity of the conflict in Turkey has tainted even the most nonviolent, distant work on behalf of Kurds.

    The Kurdish issue is multigenerational; Cansiz was in her fifties and a founding member of the P.K.K., but Soylemez was twenty-four. Dogan would have turned thirty-two on the day her body was returned to Turkey. Far from being an issue relegated to feuding older generations, young Kurds have internalized the brutality of their parents’ generation. Local sociologists refer to them as the “nineties generation”—Kurds who were children during the harsh nineteen-nineties, and respond to their parents’ wrenching testimonies and their own vague memories by rebelling against the Turkish state. Nazan Ustundag is one of these sociologists studying the impact of the conflict on young Kurds. “How do you become somebody in Turkey if you are a Kurdish person?” she asked one day last year, when we met for coffee in Istanbul. “They cannot be assimilated. Those days are over.”

    Last week, the bodies of Cansiz, Soylemez, and Dogan were returned to Turkey, to be buried. In Diyarbakir, southeast Turkey’s most important city, they were met by thousands of mourners, who followed the flag-draped coffins as they were carried through the crowd. Protests are common in Diyarbakir, and often devolve into clashes between protesters and police, but that day they were peaceful. Baris Alen, who works in the mayor’s office, told me that the major difference between the gathering that day and previous demonstrations was “the attitude of the police force. It was obvious they were trying not to disturb the event.” Speeches, too—even those from the families of the murdered women—revealed that both sides were still focused on peace. “Basically we can say that Kurdish people strongly support the peace process,” Alen said.

    There is reason for optimism. The bodies of the three women left Paris and landed in Turkey, and brought with them the cameras and pens and curious, mournful eyes not just of the Kurds who left their homes and jobs in Diyarbakir to attend the demonstration, but the Kurds living in Europe and the Turks ready for peace. These murders—as vicious as they were—could be a turning point for Turkey. Given the political activism that marked the lives of Dogan, Soylemez, and Cansiz, it is a worthy legacy.

    Photograph: Bulent Kilic/AFP/Getty

    Read more: https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/murders-in-paris-but-perhaps-peace-in-turkey#ixzz2J6uTkMmN
  • FM: Turkey against unilateral intervention in Mali

    FM: Turkey against unilateral intervention in Mali

    Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu has stated that Ankara is against the unilateral intervention in Mali, adding that all efforts to restore Mali’s territorial integrity should be carried out under the United Nations umbrella.

    Davutoglu_230811French ground troops last Wednesday pressed northward in Mali toward territory occupied for months by militants in the start of a land assault that came after five days of air strikes that did little to erode rebel gains.

    Speaking as a guest speaker of the semi-official Anatolia news agency Editorial Desk on Friday, Davutoglu assessed current topics from Turkey’s foreign policy, including the Syrian crisis, to the French military intervention in Mali, the latest developments from Iraq as well as Turkish-Israeli relations.

    Davutoglu’s remarks regarding the intervention in Mali were the first comments by a Turkish official since the French-led military operation in Mali, aided by the country’s African neighbors and Western powers to fight against rebels who occupied the northern provinces, began eight days ago.

    Northern Mali fell under rebel control after a March military coup in Bamako triggered a Tuareg-led rebel offensive that seized the north and split the West African nation in two.

    The minister’s Mali remarks came a day after the Foreign Affairs Ministry released a diplomatically written statement with no clear position on Ankara’s stance on the issue.

    Turkey on Thursday said Ankara is closely monitoring the developments in Mali and it will continue supporting international efforts to restore national reconciliation and democracy through free elections as fighting raged on the eighth day of the French-led military intervention to wrest back

    via FM: Turkey against unilateral intervention in Mali – Trend.Az.

  • Mourners in Turkey protest killings of Kurdish activists

    Mourners in Turkey protest killings of Kurdish activists

    By Ivan Watson and Gul Tuysuz, CNN
    January 17, 2013 — Updated 1459 GMT (2259 HKT)

     

    130117115809-turkey-kurds-coffins-story-top

    Thousands of Kurds in Diyarbakir carry the coffins of the three Kurdish activists shot dead in Paris

    Diyarbakir, Turkey (CNN) — Thousands took to the streets Thursday in the predominantly Kurdish city of Diyarbakir, Turkey, to mourn three political activists killed last week in execution-style shootings in France.

    The women were saluted as the “three flowers of Kurdistan” by a mourner using a sound system atop a bus, while some carried portraits of the victims or signs reading “Sakine Cansiz is immortal.”

    Read more: Kurds rally in Paris over murder of 3 women activists

    Cansiz, one of the three killed, was one of the co-founders of the Kurdistan Workers Party or PKK, a Kurdish rebel group that has waged a guerrilla war against the Turkish state since 1984.

    Also killed were Leyla Sonmez and Fidan Dogan. French authorities said the bodies of the three women were discovered in the Information Center of Kurdistan in Paris. No arrests have been made in their deaths so far.

    Read more: How Paris killings could renew Kurdish flashpoint

    Many in Turkey fear that the triple killings could derail delicate peace talks between the Turkish government and the PKK. More than 40,000 people have been killed in the nearly 30-year conflict.

    Turkey, the United States and the European Union have labeled the PKK a terrorist organization.

    Kurdish activists accuse the Turkish government of decades of discriminatory policies against the country’s largest ethnic group. Turkish security forces have arrested thousands of Kurds in recent years on suspicion of terrorist activities.

    Last fall, the Turkish government initiated a new attempt at dialogue with Abdullah Ocalan, the PKK leader serving a life sentence in a prison on the Turkish island of Imrali.

    In what appeared to be a sign of good will, Turkish authorities allowed the bodies of the three women, all Turkish citizens, to be repatriated from France.

    Brigades of Turkish riot police armed with machine guns and gas masks fanned out across the grounds Thursday where mourners were gathered, even as Kurdish politicians denounced Turkey’s prime minister and some carried portraits of Ocalan.

    Kurdish leaders said they, too, were working to reduce tensions in the wake of the killings.

    “Here the people of of Kurdistan, by claiming ownership of these three revolutionary women, are showing that they will not fall prey to provocation,” said Sebahat Tuncel, a member of Turkey’s parliament from the pro-Kurdish Peace and Democracy Party.

    “We showed our attitude beyond any doubt, that we are for peace, for freedom, and for a democratic and peaceful resolution of the Kurdish issue.”

    In recent days, the Turkish military bombed suspected PKK camps in the Qandil Mountains of northern Iraq. On Wednesday, a Turkish police officer was killed in “an armed attack on a police car,” according to the office of the governor of the southeastern province of Mardin.

    “They say peace on the one hand, but then they bomb Qandil. In short, we have no trust left in the prime minister,” said a middle-aged Kurdish man attending Thursday’s funeral demonstration. The man asked not to be identified for security reasons.

    “The peace process has already been stalled. It didn’t even begin.”

    The atmosphere in Diyarbakir was subdued Thursday, with nearly every shop shuttered, in a citywide shutdown coinciding with the funeral demonstration.

    Kurdish politicians from the BDP told CNN they would accompany the bodies of the three murdered women to their hometowns of Maras, Tunceli, and Adana for burial later this week.

    via Mourners in Turkey protest killings of Kurdish activists – CNN.com.