MUSTAFA: Film that shows Turkey’s founder as a womanizer and heavy drinker drawing crowds, controversy

turkey flag
Spread the love

ANKARA, Turkey (AP) _ A documentary that portrays the revered founder of modern Turkey as a lonely womanizer with a weakness for alcohol and cigarettes is drawing massive crowds but outraging hardline followers of Mustafa Kemal Ataturk’s secular tradition.

More than a half-million people have watched “Mustafa” since it premiered Oct. 29 on the 85th anniversary of the Turkish republic, making it one of the most-seen films in Turkey in recent years.

But hardline secularists are livid over its portrait of Ataturk as an authoritarian leader who was detached from the people and spent his final days smoking and drinking alone.

Turkey’s top mobile telephone operator, Turkcell, withdrew its sponsorship after watching portions of the documentary before its release, fearing association with the documentary could cost it customers. And two university professors filed a formal complaint with a court in Istanbul on Monday demanding an investigation into the film’s director, journalist Can Dundar, for “eroding Ataturk’s respectability.” Insulting Ataturk is a crime in Turkey.

“Ataturk is the glue that holds the Turkish people together, he is its leader, a model personality,” professors Ahmet Ercan and Orhan Kural wrote.

Ataturk became a hero for his fearless leadership against Britain and its allies in the World War I battle of Gallipoli and went on to lead his demoralized, occupied nation to independence in 1922. He embarked on a series of radical reforms aimed at turning overwhelmingly Muslim Turkey into a European-style democracy — abolishing the Ottoman caliphate, giving the vote to women, restricting Islamic dress and replacing the Arabic script with the Roman alphabet.

Admirers say he created a model nation that shows that democracy and Islam can blend. Ataturk is idolized as the personification of that tradition 70 years after his death at age 58 of cirrhosis of the liver. His portrait is virtually ubiquitous, on home, school and office walls, currency and even jewelry such as tie pins and shirt buttons.

But Islamists dislike Ataturk for reforms that reduced religion’s role and banned religious orders such as the Sufis.

“Mustafa” does not delve deeply into Ataturk’s bravery and achievements and critics say it devotes too much time to his weaknesses. It depicts him as afraid of the dark and terrified by a distant cloud of dust he thinks is kicked up by soldiers loyal to the Ottoman sultan who are trying to get him. It turns out to be a herd of animals passing in the distance.

The two-hour documentary narrated by Dundar shows Ataturk often alone, melancholic and spending his days in the palace in Ankara, the capital he founded, drinking a bottle of the traditional Turkish spirit raki and smoking three packs a day. Critics say Ataturk was rarely alone and that his dinners were lively occasions where state affairs and reforms were discussed.

Critics have also slammed the documentary for showing Ataturk’s establishment of a secular system as motivated by vengeance for being punished by a religious education teacher at school.

Yigit Bulut, a popular columnist for the Vatan newspaper, called the film “freaky” and the “latest attempt of an effort to belittle Ataturk in the eyes of the people.”

“Do not watch the documentary, prevent people from watching it and most important of all, do not allow your children to see it and prevent the seeds that belittle Ataturk from being sowed into their subconscious minds,” he wrote.

Dundar has conceded he was wrong to portray the secular reforms as “vengeance” but defends his work as a realistic depiction of a man seen too long as beyond criticism.

“I wanted to present Ataturk to the new generation through cinema,” Dundar told The Associated Press. “I wanted to present a warmer, a more human side to Ataturk.”

“I knew the film would be spark a debate but I was surprised by the petty things the film was criticized for,” Dundar said “I have been criticized because he appears to be short in some photos or because he smoked.”

Critics also say the documentary suggests Ataturk was a womanizer. It touches on his brief marriage and alleged romances without going into details. Part of the film is based on letters he wrote a lover from the war front.

“For the first time we see a leader writing love letters from the front,” Dundar told the AP. “This is beautiful. I cannot understand how people come to the conclusion that the film depicts Ataturk as a womanizer.”

Related topic galleries: Democracy, World War I, Clothing and Textiles Industry, Health and Safety at School, Movies, Islam


Spread the love

Comments

2 responses to “MUSTAFA: Film that shows Turkey’s founder as a womanizer and heavy drinker drawing crowds, controversy”

  1. mahmadilyas Avatar
    mahmadilyas

    It is True that Mustafa Kamal Pasha was a brave warrior and a strong political leader that Turkey needed badly in the time of the final collapse of its territory. Turkey was saved by being divided into five parts by the contesting powers for the land. No Mullah or religious leader was there at the time to rescue the nation of Turks of Anatolya from that great disaster to follow. It was the Mustafa Pasha who did that great job.
    The other point is that Mustpha Kamal was the ambassador of secularism then certainly he might have some personal links or attachments with the entertainments of that system so the secularists need not blame those who are propagating that. It was the way and the preaching of Mustapha Kamal which does not ban saying or showing something so these secularists need enjoy all that. If Mustafa Kamal is considered to be an honorable guy to be shown in decent manner only then that is not according to the teachings of Secularism, that turns to Islamism.

  2. Ben Avatar
    Ben

    Ataturk saved the only islamitic country from colonisation (Egpyt, Irak, Algeria, etc: all had been the slaves of the western imperialism).

    If Turkey had faced such a history, it would act like all these enslaved countries. Nowadays you can see everywhere in the world that the humilation of being colonisated effects a country for a long time.

    Moslims from Turkey shouldn’t forget that, Ataturk saved them from such a disgrace.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More posts